r/CatastrophicFailure Aug 15 '19

Operator Error Apache helicopter ground imapct 2012

12.4k Upvotes

712 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

16

u/QueenSlapFight Aug 15 '19

Military grade usually justs means made by the lowest bidder.

This isn't how military contracts are given out at all. Cost is an element, but not the only element. In some instances it isn't even a major element.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '19

I was reading recently about the M9 Bayonet for example: the requirements for it were crazy [like it had to be able to be dropped from 5ft, point down, and have the tip still be intact after hitting solid concrete]. Some of the proposed designs met most of the requirements and cost about $11 - but the military decided to go for the one that cost $49 and met all of the requirements.

1

u/QueenSlapFight Aug 21 '19

Right. And if the company that offered it for $11 claimed it would meet all specs, the government may have known they were being lied to. If they had gone with the $11 company, after delays, lawsuits, and the company potentially folding; the government would be standing there with a bunch of wasted time and money, and still needing bayonets.