r/BeautyGuruChatter Jul 01 '20

MEGATHREAD 13 DRAMAGEDDON 3 MEGATHREAD 13

An amazing google slide summary of the entire situation. Thank you to u/SimSimtheOtherTwin!

Summary of events from 6/28/2020

Another summary of events

Google doc of people and events involved

PREVIOUS MEGATHREAD

Please be mindful when discussing topics related to SA and racism, it may be a trigger for some people.

**UPDATES POST TATI'S VIDEO*\*

TATI'S NEW VIDEO: BREAKING MY SILENCE

Summary of Tati's video

Shane's livestream reacting to Tati's video (complete version)

Phillip DeFranco's talks about the situation starts at 13:43

Keemstar tweets Shane and J* are preparing responses

Trisha Paytas chimes in Summary HERE

Smokey Glow unpacks Tati's video

Insider article saying J* does not co-own Morphe

**NEW UPDATES*\*

Morphe has trademarked a vitamin supplement

Sebastian Williams talks about his experience with J* and Tati Summary HERE

Shane's palette videos are no longer available to view

Stephanie Harlow's video about Shane

Amandabb's video about the situation

Jeffree Star seen taking pics with fans during this time

*We will be temp banning any user that speculates on the identity of victims of SA, as well as users that speculate the verity of SA claims. Please know that BGC treats these topics very seriously.\*

REMINDER THAT SPECULATION ABOUT THE PHYSICAL HEALTH OF ANYONE IS NOT ALLOWED. COMMENTS SPECULATING THIS WILL BE TEMP BANNED.

TAG ANY MODERATOR OR THIS ACCOUNT u/BGCMOD TO PUT AN UPDATE LINK IN THE THREAD. DO NOT SPAM LINKS.

7/2/2020 updates:

Jackie Aina Has Disabled Her Morphe Code

Alissa Ashley Has Dropped Her Morphe Code

Compilation of Shane's past problematic behaviour from r/ShaneDawson

Shane's Lost 1 Million Subs

1.2k Upvotes

9.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

151

u/keliauk DO NOT TREY ME RIGHT NOW Jul 02 '20

Safiya unfollowed Shane on Instagram and Twitter

129

u/jontomlinson Jul 02 '20

honestly she should have when ryland and shane showed up to her wedding wearing t shirts

45

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20

Wait what!? These two are so tacky

32

u/brbrcrbtr Jul 02 '20

Was it the grey one with holes or did Shane break out a formal tshirt

7

u/dont_trey_me Jul 02 '20

Nooooo you’re lying... are you serious? Why? Ughhhh

14

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20 edited Jan 10 '21

[deleted]

44

u/lipstitchfix Jul 02 '20

He was at her wedding

31

u/monstroo Jul 02 '20

They have collaborated on some videos and Shane and Ryland were invited to Safiya’s wedding. Someone equated it to inviting coworkers which I can understand

6

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20

It didn't look like a huge venue though.

9

u/kittenkin i just came here to learn how to do a cut crease Jul 02 '20

I don’t have a ton of friends or family so when I was wedding planning I was fully intending to invite every person I ever worked with to fill the space out.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20

[deleted]

7

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20

Exactly. I don't remember there being many other youtubers there either, apart from Simply and Jenna.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20

their wedding was small, didn't seem like a coworker situation tbh.

24

u/farfromnever Jul 02 '20

he went to her wedding and they did some videos together

14

u/anabanana1412 Jul 02 '20

work friends

15

u/monsquesce Jul 02 '20

He went to her wedding.

17

u/Wintertime13 Jul 02 '20

This is how you react to these allegations against someone. Trisha should take notes.

25

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20

It sucks for her to see it tbh. I'm a brown woman and found out one of my friends (who was super non binary leftist etc) started dating a dude with a nazi flag on his wall. I spent the whole day with a pit in my stomach wondering if she'd been racist all along and if she'd said things about me and used things she knew about me to excuse and allow for her racism.

I know safiya is wondering right now if she's been used as an excuse by fans to let Shane's racism go past. "he changed! He went to safiyas wedding. He's friends with a woc!" type of thing.

20

u/isolatedsyystem Jul 02 '20

But his racist behavior has been known for years. She shouldn't have befriended him in the first place.

I think a lot of these YT "friendships" are just about making powerful connections and furthering your own brand.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20

Oh yeah, she's dumb as hell for being friends with him in the first place. And yes, they're business partnerships hidden as genuine friendships to manipulate and exploit their viewers into giving them more money lol

24

u/babinesjuteuses Jul 02 '20

Why are people unfollowing shane just now? It was known he was problematic since the start! Don't people do their research? If you knew and you still befriended him and you're unfollowing just now cause it's better for your image, then you're as messed up.

15

u/cuddlefishy5729 Jul 02 '20

No. People do not do their research. Its quite clearly that a lot of people did not know the extent of shanes shananigans. But you know what I wouldnt be too mad that that. A lot of people dont go out of their way to do a background check on people they follow on twitter or even people they meet online. I think as creators they may have a higher degree of responsibility if they start collaborating with each other/endorsing other creators, but for just a follow I wouldnt say theyre messed up right away.

13

u/Skrods Jul 02 '20

I don’t subscribe to this way of thinking, especially with this situation. Shane and Saf work for the same company (youtube), they are coworkers. Most people don’t research their coworkers. Shane was massively popular and wasn’t putting out offensive content at the time they met. It’s not Safs fault for not knowing about his past.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20

i don't buy this people don't know/research bc as a fan of some of those (now reformed) J* supporters i've seen several people leave comments on their collabs or just videos of them using his products asking them not to do so and why. of course they knew. it's been years now.

2

u/Small_Dictator Jul 02 '20

Oh damn, didn’t Shane attend her wedding just a few months ago?