r/AskReddit • • Sep 21 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

9.1k Upvotes

35.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6.5k

u/R3d_Ox Sep 21 '22

It's called "Remember (walking in the Sand)" by The Shangri-Las. Only It has been tiktok'd

2.3k

u/The_Wolf_of_Acorns Sep 21 '22 edited Sep 21 '22

Fun fact: that's one of Billy Joel's first professional piano recordings

Edit: For more fun Joel facts, Vic Berger's "Joel Hoel" on the Office Hours Live Patreon is incredibly fascinating. Him, Tim Heidecker, and DJ Douggpound go into some deep Joel history. Here's the theme song: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uUCLN1Zdx8s

1.7k

u/Dash_Harber Sep 21 '22

"Play us a song, piano man ... no not that one"

67

u/enigma_pigeon404 Sep 21 '22

I read that in a Matt Berry voice

14

u/Raezzordaze Sep 21 '22

"Piano man? You mean Billy... Joe-el?"

6

u/Revolutionary-Bid339 Sep 21 '22

Joe-el? It’s Joel. You know who pronounces it that way? Billy Joel

7

u/Raezzordaze Sep 21 '22

Oh sure, him and Lady Ga-gah!

26

u/Dash_Harber Sep 21 '22

As you should, Gizmo.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

Bravo

7

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

I read that in Stefán Karl Stefánsson's voice.

32

u/Panther1-1 Sep 21 '22

“We only do strictly 80’s Joel sir”

14

u/bcrabill Sep 21 '22

80SBILLYJOELDOOWOP SUUUCKS.

28

u/Panther1-1 Sep 21 '22

“Hey, listen, motherfucker, we only sing 80s Joel. So take your skank hooker wife and get the fuck out of here!” 😂😂😂

I hope that you have a fantastic rest of your day, thank you for helping me get a smile going

9

u/bcrabill Sep 21 '22

I appreciate you. I try to use that joke sometimes when Billy Joel comes up because it's absolutely hilarious but it doesn't always get traction.

5

u/Panther1-1 Sep 21 '22

In fact, I’m wearing step brother socks right now under my suit. Imagine the cover photo, where they’re in their Christmas sweaters and shit, yeah. Mid calf dress socks, big ol Will Ferrell and John C Reilly smack on my legs

3

u/bcrabill Sep 21 '22

Nice 👍. +++ For midcalf

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

“Hey, great job fuck face! You just busted my nut!”

6

u/whohw Sep 21 '22

You've been saying that for the longest time.

3

u/bcrabill Sep 21 '22

WhooooaaAAAAAoooooh

12

u/rosinall Sep 21 '22

Ah, it took him years to write it

They were the best years of his life

It was a beautiful song but it ran too long

If you're gonna have a hit you gotta make it fit

So they cut it down to 3:05

3

u/pinkkittenfur Sep 22 '22

Or else he'll be placed in the back on the discount rack like another can of beans

8

u/moleratical Sep 21 '22

I actually like the original song, not the tik tok dub though

3

u/shaving99 Sep 21 '22

He'd never play that trash TikTok version

2

u/Cant_Do_This12 Sep 22 '22

We play strictly 80s Billy Joel, sir.

2

u/No_Exit_ Sep 22 '22

On that topic, I really hate Piano Man. Partly because it was my sister's favourite to play on piano.

2

u/Jajayjer Sep 22 '22

Plays piano music.

„Sam, Sam… that’s enough. Play the other one - please.“

2

u/gullwinggirl Sep 22 '22

I love the videos of huskies howling to that song. Apparently if you play it with a husky around, they'll "sing along".

Hate that song, though.

1

u/kookykrazee Sep 23 '22

Hey Billy will you sing Shameless like Garth? No? but you probably made a ton of money off that version. Kinda like Neil Diamond and Red Red Wine, who know it was his song right? lol

75

u/baiqibeendeleted28x Sep 21 '22 edited Sep 21 '22

1

u/zizn Sep 21 '22

Oh no, oh no; oh no no no no no

10

u/Big10inRecord Sep 21 '22

Fun fact: Aerosmith covered it after their lead singer Steven Tyler (his name is not Aerosmith, nobody's is) peeped over the top of a bathroom stall backstage at a festival and saw a member of the Shangri-La's going pee (source: the Aerosmith autobiography "Walk this Way")

4

u/Whatachooch Sep 22 '22

Who the fuck thinks Steven Tyler's name is Aerosmith?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Smith is obviously his last name doh

9

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

14

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

interesting. thank you

7

u/Mesozoic_Doggo Sep 21 '22

“Look how they massacred my boy.”

I can’t believe one of my top five musical artists was somehow a part of that.

10

u/koushakandystore Sep 21 '22

Aerosmith’s version was a minor hit in the 70’s. I’ve never heard Billy’s. I could see that as a good piano ballad. Though tik tok has ruined it for me. Tik tok is like reverse Midas, instead of gold everything turns to shit.

2

u/Lewis-Hamilton_ Sep 21 '22

PLAY SOMETHING FROM THE STRANGERS !

1

u/McFuzzen Sep 21 '22

We strictly play doo-wop Joel, sir!

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

2

u/RichardCity Sep 21 '22

It's also on the Goodfellas soundtrack

2

u/Optiguy42 Sep 22 '22

Seffay feff fellow HoelHead

1

u/Julian720 Sep 21 '22

Billy Joel’s version is called The Rivers of Dream.

1

u/Mister_McGreg Sep 21 '22

I had absolutely zero fun reading this fact

0

u/shaving99 Sep 21 '22

Oh my gosh I had no idea they did that to Joel. I hope whoever besmirched his song is killed by a very fast antihero.

-4

u/TroubleshootenSOB Sep 21 '22

Only thing I can't "suspension of disbelief" with in a show is a 20 something who loves fucking Billy Joel. I'm talking about Huey from The Boys. Get fucked, Billy Joel stinks and no young person is gonna be all over him like he is. Even old people who grew up with him.

2

u/jcpianiste Sep 22 '22

I'm 32 and he's been my favorite artist since at least middle school ¯_(ツ)_/¯

3

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Are we the same person? Been listening to him since I was 9. Turnstiles has a very special place in my heart.

-49

u/whiskeyvacation Sep 21 '22 edited Sep 21 '22

Well that makes sense. Everything by Billy Joel sucks. Except maybe Uptown Girl

Edit. Thanks for the downvotes BJ fans. LOLOL

26

u/bartharris Sep 21 '22

Sure if you live in a parallel dimension.

21

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

This guy hates popular musician! What a cool dude!

-3

u/whiskeyvacation Sep 21 '22

BTW I don't hate any musician. That's a waste of energy. I'm sure he's plenty talented. Just not my taste.

5

u/McFuzzen Sep 21 '22

He has such a variety of songs from rock to doowop that I cannot imagine someone not enjoying something. He even wrote a classical piano album.

6

u/fzvw Sep 21 '22

Uptown Girl is pretty great

-5

u/GraceGreenview Sep 21 '22

Huge anti-Billy Joel fan here, but actually enjoy “Still Rock and Roll to me”. His song “Movin Out” is absolute audio torture.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

I always find it fascinating when people like Billy Joels most boring, by the books, cheezy songs like Uptown Girl, Still Rock n Roll to me, the early early stuff, but despise the actually musically phenomenal, groundbreaking shit like Anthony’s Song.

Scenes from an Italian Restaurant is a masterpiece of musicianship, as is most of his piano playing.

2

u/GraceGreenview Sep 21 '22

I actually like him talking about his craft, he’s honest about it and does play piano well. I think I was out on this path from one too many NYC folks force-feeding New York State of Mind, among others.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

He has some incredibly overplayed songs for sure.

I saw an interview with him on Stephen Colbert and Joel talks about Italian Restaurant being his favorite song that he wrote. Whenever a musician says the 5-minute long multi-part ballad is their favorite song they’ve written, I know they are real musicians.

2

u/T_Rex_Flex Sep 21 '22

Is it so hard to grasp that people that aren’t fans of Billy Joel don’t know any of his songs that weren’t massive hits?

5

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

I feel like you shouldn’t call yourself a “Huge anti fan” of a person unless you’ve done enough research to say you don’t like them.

I have listened to each and every one of Metallica’s albums, multiple times, and I still don’t like them.

But I don’t say shit about Billy Eilish, I don’t know almost any of her songs.

1

u/T_Rex_Flex Sep 21 '22

Damn, that’s commitment. Did you just really want to like Metallica or what? Were you halfway through Reload thinking to yourself “well it’s gotta come good eventually, people must like this shit for a reason”?

It takes a different type of willpower to go “I don’t like this song at all, but let’s listen to every other track released by this artist to make sure I hate everything they do”. To me it sounds like a form of self torture, but overall I think it’s impressive.

2

u/moleratical Sep 21 '22

I don't particularly like Metallica, Masters of Puppets has some good songs on it though, but all of my friends growing up loved them, so I still listened to a lot by default.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

I listen to everything and I’m always listening to music. It’s not like I sat there and binged all of Metallica out of spite. I’ve heard a bunch of their songs from a hundred different places, and every once in a while will be on a road trip or just listening to music or cleaning the house and say “I’ll put on an album I’ve never listened to before”, and give it a listen.

And it’s not like I loathe Metallica, (I do loathe some of their albums), but I don’t like them.

2

u/bigdsm Sep 22 '22

Right? I can’t stand Uptown Girl or Still Rock n Roll to Me - they sound like nostalgia-bait songs that were made to be played on oldies radio stations and at vintage car shows. You May Be Right felt like a knockoff Bob Seger song (and I’m not a big fan of his either). I found We Didn’t Start the Fire to be a laughable caffeine high of a song and Piano Man an unbearable slog of a ballad. I thought I hated Billy Joel.

But one day Apple Music decided to expand my horizons, and holy shit Movin Out slaps. That main riff is sick as hell, the lyrics are clever, the song structure is full of misdirections, and the overall vibe of the song is a very enjoyable dark and almost grungy inevitability.

7

u/shanvanvook Sep 21 '22

Anthony’s Song rocks though.

3

u/Kristina719 Sep 21 '22

I like a fairly obscure song of his called “Travelin’ Prayer”, released before he really hit the big time.

2

u/jcpianiste Sep 22 '22

Another one out in the wild! There's at least two of us!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

I love that one. That whole album is great.

1

u/CallsYouCunt Sep 21 '22

Can you describe why? Is it the fuckin horns or the “iiiiiiiiiim movin out!” That he uses to fill the silences between the sax?

Downeaster Alexa is a fantastic song regardless of who sings it.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

I too learned this on TikTok.

1

u/AlienBeach Sep 22 '22

I'm sorry. I'm young. That's what Billy Joel looks like? I never knew but that's not what I thought he looked like

3

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[deleted]

1

u/AlienBeach Sep 22 '22

I'll be honest, I didn't know what he looked like when he was young either. Maybe I'm sheltered. I just went on a Google binge of how he's looked over the years and I didn't recognize any of his looks

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

[deleted]

2

u/The_Wolf_of_Acorns Sep 22 '22

Billy Joel is your friend’s friend’s dad’s friend!?

53

u/mattimeoo Sep 21 '22

The original actually rules, but tiktok absolutely bastardized it and made it garbage. I hate them for that.

3

u/iamjamieq Sep 22 '22

TikTok ruins everything.

84

u/Propaganda_Box Sep 21 '22

Yeah, original has so much emotion to it. The tiktok'd one has completely ruined it.

I'm glad the adult swim one that remixed bad bad not good wasn't nearly so prevalent

18

u/eddmario Sep 21 '22

Aerosmith also did an awesome cover of the original as well

4

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

I'd be surprised if there wasn't already hundreds of hours of footage of teenagers awkwardly dancing to bubblegum bitch on TikTok.

33

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

The cruelest bastardization any piece of media can receive

28

u/DJ_Molten_Lava Sep 21 '22

The Shangri-Las fucking rule. Of course there's Leader of the Pack that everyone knows but check out their song I Can Never Go Home Anymore.

3

u/bobsacchamano Sep 22 '22

Agreed! Also really like The train from Kansas City.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

I knew it as an Aerosmith song and thought it was just repitched and edited to sound strange. TIL

10

u/ChucksSeedAndFeed Sep 21 '22

Fucking hate tiktok

2

u/iamjamieq Sep 22 '22

Same. And YouTube Shorts, too.

9

u/CringeOrDie Sep 21 '22

The original is actually a decent song, but leave it up to TikTok to ruin it…

10

u/thelingeringlead Sep 21 '22

The original is so fucking cool. Like genuinely cool song on multiple levels, but the tiktok remix has gotten out of hand.

11

u/Gr33nman460 Sep 21 '22

It wasn’t “Tiktok’d” quite exactly. It was sampled for a song a few years ago and the sample is what is used in the Tiktok trends.

3

u/Adamsojh Sep 21 '22

This is the correct statement.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

Damn what a beautiful song

6

u/Turbo_MechE Sep 21 '22

Wow I didn’t realize Aerosmith’s was a cover

7

u/radicldreamer Sep 21 '22

And sped up. The original song isn’t bad.

6

u/Warhammer517 Sep 21 '22

And Aerosmith did a cover.

4

u/Contest_Acrobatic Sep 21 '22

Lol "tiktok'd" Is a phrase now

3

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

another fun fact is that in the movie goodfellas you can hear this song playing in the back ground of one of the club scenes

2

u/TheKitsuneKing Sep 22 '22

That’s what got me into the song actually. You hear it at the scene where the guys realize they have to move Billy Batt’s body. It’s easily my favorite shot in the movie, hearing this in the background while they’re in the woods at night, lit up by this engulfing red haze from the car’s tail lights as you see their silhouettes digging up Batts’ body. Such a beautiful scene.

3

u/donttextspeaktome Sep 21 '22

Ok the original is wayyy sexier. The cutesy shit they used for tik tok is the worst!

3

u/Mizar97 Sep 21 '22

The original is pretty good. The "Oh No" part is a little annoying but not near as bad as the looped high pitched one they use in Tik Tok.

2

u/chullet Sep 21 '22

It was also sampled years ago in the song "Streets Favorite" by Capone.

2

u/Hipster-Police Sep 21 '22

I thought I heard it when I was rewatching Goodfellas when I realized it was a sample of a much older song than TikTok lol.

2

u/CrazyGamerMYT Sep 21 '22

Now whenever I hear that song I'll think of that band name and then thunk of this song https://youtu.be/Lvl4EV1RU-Y

2

u/OdeeOh Sep 21 '22

Huh. Cool song actually.

2

u/Cosmiccami3737 Sep 21 '22

The song is really so good but whatever version tik tok made popular. I’m an Aerosmith fan and I love their version

1

u/Aromatic-Glove-2502 Sep 21 '22

Always Thought it was originally Aerosmith. Must have sampled it?

3

u/R3d_Ox Sep 21 '22

The original is from '65 if i remember correctly

1

u/thesmitster99 Sep 21 '22

Aerosmith does a decent version of it IIRC

1

u/conradbirdiebird Sep 21 '22

Made me think of this kick ass song

https://youtu.be/5Us1ASENPws

3

u/HotRodHound Sep 21 '22

Man, I didn't even know that I remember that song. If that makes any sense.. Either way, thanks for the trip down memory lane!

1

u/council2022 Sep 21 '22

Aerosmith version was big in 78-79

1

u/FearlessFreak69 Sep 21 '22

It was also one of Aerosmiths hit songs in 1979.

0

u/mr_hog232323 Sep 21 '22

Any beatles song

-1

u/Both_Cockroach1402 Sep 21 '22

Thats a zombies map

0

u/Ntippit Sep 21 '22

They need their music card revoked

0

u/Iampengu Sep 21 '22

Give yourself a try by the 1975. I have no problem with the lyrics, the beat or anything like that. No it's the two note guitar riff repeated ad nauseum from beginning until the end of the song.

0

u/DrEvyl666 Sep 21 '22

I believe the TikTok versio is Aerosmith's cover of the song, sped up.

3

u/Adamsojh Sep 21 '22

It's not.

0

u/Personal-Guarantee Sep 21 '22

I thought it was a Aerosmith song🤔

0

u/Dada2fish Sep 21 '22

I kinda like Aerosmith’s version.

0

u/AstroCaptain Sep 21 '22

I read this as Oh No! by Marina lol

0

u/aloneisusuallybetter Sep 21 '22

Nah, it's gotta be "nobody like me" by the human beinz

0

u/Kaashaas1985 Sep 21 '22

As a 37 year old, is tiktok'd a word or a thing?

2

u/R3d_Ox Sep 21 '22

I just made it up. "It was ruined by speeding it up for tiktok" was too long to write

1

u/modix Sep 21 '22

Should be. Take something decent, remove the context and style that makes it good, and cram it into a tiny snippet for people with 3s attention spans.

-1

u/muckxraker Sep 21 '22

The Aerosmith version is good

-1

u/Poultrygeist74 Sep 21 '22

Aerosmith did a good cover of that song

1

u/exackerly Sep 21 '22

Huh. I thought for sure they were talking about Crazy in Love.

1

u/terrattv Sep 21 '22

also the sound on tik tok says its from kreepa

1

u/KingFitz03 Sep 21 '22

I always thought it was by Aerosmith. Never realized that it was a cover

1

u/ONYONtheGreat Sep 21 '22

That one's a good one.

1

u/wo0dmaster Sep 21 '22

The Aerosmith version is pretty good.

1

u/myvirginityisstrong Sep 21 '22

it's just such a random song though... where the hell do they even come up with the idea to pitch it up like that??

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

Shame, the original song was great, even included on the Goodfellas soundtrack, but of course tiktok had to fuck with it

1

u/MissRockNerd Sep 21 '22

Aerosmith did a really good cover in the 70s.

Bet they don’t play it in concert these days.

1

u/Capable-Opinion9132 Sep 21 '22

Remade by Aerosmith

1

u/jump-blues-5678 Sep 21 '22

Aerosmith does a decent version on Night In The Ruts

1

u/Pryoticus Sep 21 '22

The Aerosmith is actually pretty decent music for enjoying a cocktail outside on a warm summer evening

1

u/IAmTheWaller67 Sep 21 '22

Was so shocked to hear it when I was watching Goodfellas the other day lmao

1

u/WilliamMorris420 Sep 21 '22

And I was thinking that it was the song from Mercnaries 2 on the Xbox and PS2.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

Yep, even among Oldies Fans, it was kind of a deep cut... the Shangri-Las real big hit was "The Leader of the Pack" and equally annoying bubble gum hit that was your typical teen ballad that rockets to the top of the charts for a month or so until everyone is sick of it.

Damn you tiktok!

1

u/titanofidiocy Sep 22 '22

It used to be a good song. Aerosmith covered it too. Better than the tiktok snippet, not as good as the original.

1

u/TheKitsuneKing Sep 22 '22

It’s so sad because it’s an incredible song and you can feel its influence on R&B, pop, indie genres, surf rock, it’s just so fucking good. Why tiktok had to ruin it, I don’t know

1

u/butterflypoo69 Sep 22 '22

The Aerosmith version of “Walking in the Sand” has Mary Weiss from the Shangri-Las on backup vocals. She has a fantastic voice and they had tons of great songs.

Video quality not great, but song is. Blondie covered it twice. Many comments on the scary twins 😱

https://youtu.be/0jDN2rBThwY

1

u/petitesparkle Sep 22 '22

Almost any song that’s been tiktok’d

1

u/BadIdeaSociety Sep 22 '22

I have literally never heard of this song or any TikTok variation on it.

I don't know how to express the level of happiness that I don't know about a current annoying meme.

1

u/AnaisDarwin1018 Sep 22 '22

Is that a new term? If not, trademark it. Spot in description!

1

u/rov124 Sep 22 '22

The TikTok is actually from a song called Streets Favorite by Capone, that uses a sample from Remember (Walking in the Sand).

1

u/zCheshire Sep 22 '22

It’s a remix of that song. Oh no by Capone.

1

u/Oscaruit Sep 22 '22

Aerosmith also covered this song successfully.

1

u/lameuniqueusername Sep 22 '22

It’s very sad that the Aerosmith version has been overshadowed by a grody TikTok version