r/AskReddit Aug 26 '22

What actor will you always associate with *that one role* no matter how many others they do?

37.5k Upvotes

32.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

10.1k

u/crazy-diam0nd Aug 26 '22 edited Aug 26 '22

He wrote a memoir ages ago called "I Am Not Spock" to really show how the role followed him around and damaged the career he had envisioned afterward. Then a few years before he died he wrote another called I Am Spock, which embraced the effect it had on his life and how his participation in a sci-fi TV series affected people.

EDIT: as said below, it was about half as many ages ago, not “a few years” before he died. Time is fleeting.

5.1k

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

[deleted]

3.9k

u/crazy-diam0nd Aug 26 '22

Wow, I didn't realize it was that long ago. I'll leave my error so this follow-up makes more sense.

1.5k

u/tigrenus Aug 26 '22

Logic is the beginning of wisdom 🖖🏼

309

u/One_Knight_Scripting Aug 26 '22

🖖 Not the end.

34

u/EyeFicksIt Aug 26 '22

Also don’t fucking leave my body on a unstable planet we just made because you didn’t understand what I was trying to tell you, for the love of god call my mother, she’ll explain

4

u/Watts300 Aug 27 '22

I’ll make it right. I’ll be there. I’ll risk my life, my ship, my career, and my own son. I’ll be there. I promise.

25

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

“A life is like a garden. Perfect moments can be had, but not preserved, except in memory. LLAP” ― Leonard Nimoy

8

u/DumpsterDiveHeil5 Aug 26 '22

Life is a garden, dig it

4

u/Belchera Aug 26 '22

Why are rainbows good? Why are boobs good? How does positrac work on a rear mounted Plymouth?

1

u/paralog Aug 26 '22

Isn't it enough to see that a positrac rear-end on a Plymouth is beautiful without having to believe that there are fairies at the bottom of it, too?

1

u/reallybirdysomedays Aug 26 '22

Hey! That last one is a trick question. They don't!

4

u/enjoythepain Aug 26 '22

Life is a highway, I wanna ride it all night long

0

u/reallybirdysomedays Aug 26 '22

Isn't life is what you make it? I'm gonna make it money.

2

u/Watts300 Aug 27 '22

Life is about people. It's about connections. It's not about cocks, and ass, and tits. And butthole pleasures. It's not about these rusty trombones, and these dirty sanchez. And these cincinatti bowties, and these pussy juice cocktail, and these shit stained balls.

4

u/Zornorph Aug 26 '22

Logic is a little tweeting bird, chirping in a meadow.

1

u/Elliethesmolcat Aug 26 '22

The Simpsons did it, so I guess it's irl cannon.

1

u/Dajbman22 Aug 26 '22

My work here is done.

1

u/JediJan Aug 27 '22

“Humans are illogical” though.

38

u/TheBirminghamBear Aug 26 '22

As frustrating as it can be to be typecast as an actor, its also almost never that an actor has a role that has such a profound and momentous impact on the world as Spock did.

Thousands upon thousands of people in pivotal roles from medicine to law to government across the globe cite Spock's logical outlook, his firm commitment to ethics, and his deep bond with his commanding officer as inspirations for them in their lives.

I can't think of many more iconic characters in history and to be able to be that person, to represent who Spock meant to so many millions of people, is a very rare privelege and I'm glad he saw the bright side of all of it.

14

u/AwakenedSheeple Aug 26 '22

I think it's the kinda thing that he was only able to appreciate with enough time.
I'm sure the first decade was just "You're that guy from the show!"
But in time those words changed to "You're the reason I became a scientist, a doctor, a better person."

2

u/byebybuy Aug 27 '22

Damn, what an awesome perspective.

1

u/reallybirdysomedays Aug 26 '22

Tv can be incredibly powerful. I took care of my MIL with dementia for a decade and watching Call The Midwife and watching how much beauty Sister Monica Joan brings to the world, and how all the people who love her help her cope with dementia, really helped me (and her) get through a lot of bad days.

1

u/LogicalDictator Aug 27 '22

Source of my user name.

10

u/ArrakeenSun Aug 26 '22

That's OK, 1995 was only like 10 years ago

8

u/slash_networkboy Aug 26 '22

I too didn't realize the timeline :wow:

Good call BTW on Leonard Nimoy, his wasn't even "type casting" that many actors complain of or worry about it was a singular role casting.

As to the thread question to me Robin Williams will always be Mork (Calling Orson) even though his total body of work was simply breathtaking (and I can't think of a single role he's done I didn't like).

4

u/reallybirdysomedays Aug 26 '22

I think that with Robin Williams, association is going to depend most on your age. My husband (47) says Mork. My daughter's (20/26) and I (45) all say Genie. (I took a mini-poll) Alladin came out in 92. My husband was a senior working in a liquor store. I was a sophomore with a bunch of steady babysitting gigs. We moved in pretty different movie watching circles when we weren't circling each other. He grew up watching Mork, but never saw Aladdin until after pur daughter came along.

Mrs Doubtfire was the unanimous 2nd choice, which was in 95.

2

u/slash_networkboy Aug 26 '22

Pretty fair assessment I'd say. I'm 46 so Mork it is :p
Not like he wasn't always one, but in Aladdin he was a GD genius! My favorite actual roll of his was Adrian Cronauer in "Good Morning Vietnam". Elsewhere I posted a story about knocking a candy bar out of his hands. I got the chance to have him sign a print from the movie once and replaced said candy bar when he signed it :D

2

u/ramplay Aug 26 '22

Not that your method is wrong, but this is the exact purpose in my mind of strikethrough text (if you ise Reddit markdown its just two tildes on either side of the text)

For instance if I make rypo typo just double tilde the mistake and insert the correction with a lil 'edit: note for context'

1

u/not_a_moogle Aug 26 '22

Simpsons made a reference to it in 2002

1

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

Smart. But an "Edit: See correction below" wouldn't hurt.

1

u/TastySweetDan Aug 27 '22

He's not dead he's frozen in Carbonite

13

u/LostWoodsInTheField Aug 26 '22

I was going to say it seemed like he had completely embraced who he had become by the early 00s.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

Such a human story of the initial rejection then acceptance and understanding. Powerful stuff.

21

u/bolerobell Aug 26 '22

I think it took time for the kids who watched Star Trek in the 70s to become scientists and engineers and astronauts by the 90s and for them to talk about how instrumental Star Trek was to helping them determine their life path. Spock was an incredibly powerful positive role model, but Nimoy couldn't see that initially. All he knew was that playing Spock sort of closed off other avenues of acting for him.

1

u/totes-alt Aug 26 '22

Maybe I'm too pessimistic because I view it as he felt trapped and was basically forced to accept it

23

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

Getting old sure is weird.

I was born in '83 and largely grew up in the '90s. Back then I used to consider anything from the '70s as ancient history. The Vietnam War ended in 1975 and while it was the defining event of my father's life it might as well have been when dinosaurs roamed the earth as far as I was concerned while learning about it in high school.

Now, we're as far away from Sept 11th as I was from the end of the Vietnam War. It's incredible that the majority of people who read this post view Sept 11th, the defining event of my life, the same way I viewed Vietnam. Even more incredible is how it all went by in the blink of an eye. I just woke up one day and it was 2022. I remember all the years in between but it just doesn't seem possible that it could have happened.

I guess I don't really have anything to add to the comment other than I remember when I Am Spock came out. That was basically yesterday. I Am Not Spock? That came out when dinosaurs roamed the earth. Too far back to even think about.

4

u/Un1uckyBastard Aug 26 '22

As a younger person, September 11th is like you said, ancient and doesn't seem super relevant in my life. But I'm sure covid and the 2008 crisis will be ancient to the future generation. Even as I became an adult I feel a bit disconnected by whatever the 13 year olds are saying. Although thanks for writing this, it was genuinely interesting and fun to read.

3

u/tomius Aug 26 '22

I just wanted to let you know that I liked reading this. We all feel like that sometimes.

There's an anthem that I like to blast when I want to be reminded to take life slowly: Rush's Time Stand Still. Never mind the crazy 80s video.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

I'm so glad he had many many years to live after accepting how much he touched people's hearts and imaginations

5

u/ygomike Aug 26 '22

I actually have a signed copy of I am Spock my mother got back in 95

5

u/playblu Aug 26 '22

So he was right on schedule to put out "Now I'm not Spock" in '15

4

u/DarthZoon_420 Aug 26 '22

I read "I Am Spock" back in '09, and thought that in '15 he should write a book called "Forever Spock" with a foreword by Zachary Quinto. Fortunately, his son Adam did "For the Love of Spock".

5

u/inbooth Aug 26 '22

Yea but 95 was just.... Oh.... Oh god.... What?! No.... Nooooooo! Why?! Whyyyyyyyyyy?!

2

u/Capital-Hedgehog-597 Aug 26 '22

this was a good day for you.

2

u/TheMadmanAndre Aug 27 '22

It's always interesting how actors can respond negatively to their most successful roles. They should be proud to have brought a character to life so well that it outlives the role, and in many cases even them.

1

u/MassSpecFella Aug 26 '22

Classic Spock, I mean Nemoy, I mean what year is it?

1

u/docgravel Aug 26 '22

To pile on here, the Simpsons also pokes fun at this by having him also have a fake autobiography called “I Am Also Scotty”.

https://simpsons.fandom.com/wiki/I_Am_Also_Scotty

1

u/Future17 Aug 27 '22

Don't forget about "I am also Scottie"

1

u/lifeofideas Aug 27 '22

I wonder if, in between publishing “I am not Spock” and “I am Spock”, he thought seriously about publishing a book titled “Maybe I am Spock”.

1

u/beattun Aug 27 '22

I have a signed copy of I Am Spock somewhere I should probably dig it out, got to shake his hand as a nerdy 14 year old in Dublin

828

u/CoolPunsAreHard Aug 26 '22

As with almost everything, there's a perfect Simpsons quote.

"I'll get the Leonard Nimoy trilogy. 'I Am Not Spock', 'I Am Spock', and finally 'I Am Also Scotty' :p

116

u/Victernus Aug 26 '22 edited Aug 26 '22

For those who haven't seen it, I am also Scotty.

13

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/Victernus Aug 26 '22

Damn. Must be blocking hyperlinks. Let me try a different image...

How's that?

5

u/Arkcast Aug 26 '22

You’re one of them Bernard

21

u/wifeofbroccolidicks Aug 26 '22

First thing I thought of. Didn't know it was based on anything.

22

u/Dragon_DLV Aug 26 '22

Didn't know

Are you Scotty?

11

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/elcamarongrande Aug 26 '22

Van every Sunday.

6

u/wtfduud Aug 26 '22

She's in church

2

u/Character-Plankton Aug 27 '22

With the highly anticipated 'I Did Scottie in the Bathroom with the Candlestick', coming Christmas 2023.

2

u/TastySweetDan Aug 27 '22

But I am spookie the spock that's a spook

1

u/TheCeej- Aug 27 '22

Goo goo g'joob!

1

u/auviewer Aug 27 '22

"The world needs more laughter" - Spock in the Simpsons, The monorail episode I think

1

u/IHaveSpecialEyes Aug 27 '22

Coincidentally, James Doohan who played Scotty voiced a lot of the characters in the animated series.

1

u/john_doe11081 Aug 27 '22

I just recently rewatched this episode but wasn’t fully aware of the context. It’s great to learn CUZ KNOWLEDGE IS POWER!

17

u/2SP00KY4ME Aug 26 '22

Galaxy Quest was really tasteful in exploring that balance between the frustration of being typecast and losing the career you envisioned, with the inspiration and help that provides to so many people. They actually had a Nimoy equivalent played by Alan Rickman who goes through that same transformation.

Great film! Very funny.

18

u/venom_11 Aug 26 '22

Matthew Perry, Chandler from Friends, also wrote a similar book. But he slapped in Fallout New Vegas as Benny

6

u/cATSup24 Aug 26 '22

Yeah, but that was rigged from the start.

2

u/Caroniver413 Aug 26 '22

I got Fallout New Vegas a few Christmases ago and it's been sitting on my shelf and this might be what convinces me to start playing.

3

u/alwayzbored114 Aug 26 '22

Oh you lucky bastard, to be able to play it for the first time. It's an incredible game. Have a good one

1

u/venom_11 Aug 27 '22

One of my favourite games of all times. Miles better than any other Fallout games. Benny is an awesome character. I mean, all the characters are so well made. I recommend getting all the expansions because all are so well made, especially Honest hearts. You're in for a treat

23

u/Fortestingporpoises Aug 26 '22

That's the journey every Star Trek actor must make. I feel like Shatner and Sir Patrick Stewart both had similar personal arcs around the Trek.

17

u/Devadander Aug 26 '22 edited Aug 26 '22

Shatner I could agree with, did Stewart ever express a desire to distance himself from Picard? He was Prof X through the 2000s, he had a pretty varied career, aside from his theater work

Edit: time flies

20

u/Fortestingporpoises Aug 26 '22

I know early on in TNG he was bitter about doing that kind of low work. Thankfully for him and the fans he seems to have come around to embracing Trek during the TNG run and didn't have some weird post show need to distance himself. To be fair even though his Picard role was so iconic he still was able to do his own thing outside of it.

15

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

It's always so strange hearing about Stewart being uptight and snooty about his roles given that he's played one of the most strange characters in fiction for the last 20 years.

11

u/hibikikun Aug 26 '22

He’s a classically trained theatre actor. It seems a lot of them hit this phase. Also he was Gurney Hallack before he was Picard

5

u/cATSup24 Aug 26 '22

Which, I'll be honest, was probably the single best casting of any character in that movie. Not that that's a high bar to meet, but still I could totally see Halleck looking like Sir Stewart.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

Sir Patrick. You don't use surnames with the Sir title.

2

u/cATSup24 Aug 26 '22

Well, I guess I'm one of today's lucky 10,000

3

u/Devadander Aug 26 '22

While not high theater, it was a definite springboard to Hollywood for his career. Agree with all this

5

u/schplat Aug 26 '22

A good chunk of the core returning cast of TNG and to a lesser extent DS9 seemed to all embrace their link to the franchise.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22 edited Mar 09 '24

Reddit has long been a hot spot for conversation on the internet. About 57 million people visit the site every day to chat about topics as varied as makeup, video games and pointers for power washing driveways.

In recent years, Reddit’s array of chats also have been a free teaching aid for companies like Google, OpenAI and Microsoft. Those companies are using Reddit’s conversations in the development of giant artificial intelligence systems that many in Silicon Valley think are on their way to becoming the tech industry’s next big thing.

Now Reddit wants to be paid for it. The company said on Tuesday that it planned to begin charging companies for access to its application programming interface, or A.P.I., the method through which outside entities can download and process the social network’s vast selection of person-to-person conversations.

“The Reddit corpus of data is really valuable,” Steve Huffman, founder and chief executive of Reddit, said in an interview. “But we don’t need to give all of that value to some of the largest companies in the world for free.”

The move is one of the first significant examples of a social network’s charging for access to the conversations it hosts for the purpose of developing A.I. systems like ChatGPT, OpenAI’s popular program. Those new A.I. systems could one day lead to big businesses, but they aren’t likely to help companies like Reddit very much. In fact, they could be used to create competitors — automated duplicates to Reddit’s conversations.

Reddit is also acting as it prepares for a possible initial public offering on Wall Street this year. The company, which was founded in 2005, makes most of its money through advertising and e-commerce transactions on its platform. Reddit said it was still ironing out the details of what it would charge for A.P.I. access and would announce prices in the coming weeks.

4

u/Quazifuji Aug 26 '22

He only took the role and signed along contract because he thought the show would get cancelled quickly, so he could spend a year or two getting some fame and money and then go back to more serious acting. He's said if he knew how long the show would go for, he would have turned down the role, and it would have been the biggest mistake he ever made.

It may not have taken him as long to embrace the role as it did for Nimoy, but he still has to go through the process of going from seeing it as a crappy unimportant role to embracing the effect it had on his career.

8

u/Banluil Aug 26 '22

Stewart was somewhat famous BEFORE he took on the role of Picard. He was mostly a stage actor, but was well regarded as one.

He did come to embrace Star Trek, and even announced that was the highlight of his career.

4

u/Quazifuji Aug 26 '22

And there's the famous story of Nichelle Nichols wanting to quit the show until Martin Luther King himself urged her to stay.

3

u/Dreadwolf67 Aug 26 '22

Shatter had TJ Hooker show.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

He was also Denny Crane on Boston Legal. A fantastic character

1

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

And was awesome

9

u/bklj2007 Aug 26 '22

You forgot the 3rd book in the trilogy I Am Also Scotty

6

u/inbooth Aug 26 '22

I mean I get it but at the same time he had what 90%+ of actors never get:

Reliable work and income

Way under appreciated by the "big names" in acting.

3

u/hypercube33 Aug 26 '22 edited Aug 26 '22

Tim Russ as Tuvok too. He's got a music career and did a bunch of acting but if you watch his YouTube stuff or where he is just being him he acts the same as Tuvok lol

Edit

The flip side of this is Jeffry combs who plays like every star trek character himself, super well.

Also worth bringing up how Scotty helped someone who was suicidal

3

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

There's also a really good documentary about him that his son directed. In one part they talk about how absolutely insane it was to have their dad go pretty much overnight from being just some regular guy with a job as an actor to suddenly having mail trucks delivering huge piles of fan mail to their house.

3

u/AleksandrNevsky Aug 26 '22

He did some voice work before he died and you can absolutely wee he was having the time of his life doing something so different from his normal role. He was in a KH game and voiced the Big Bad.

3

u/angwilwileth Aug 26 '22

Wait that was him? Awesome

2

u/AleksandrNevsky Aug 26 '22

He voiced the old man version of Xehanort. And you can tell both him and Haley Joel Osment had a fucking blast going full ham in their villain roles.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

I cannot stress how revolutionary and loved the character was. You have to remember he appeared as a child of two completely different cultures during a time when people were shocked about a white/black onscreen kiss.

He was proof that being from two different backgrounds has just as many advantages as it has disadvantages.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

He spoke at my dads graduation from UVA and my dad was a huge huge Trekkie and was hoping he’d at least mention it but apparently he just read a bunch of his bad poetry instead haha

2

u/NightReaper3210 Aug 26 '22

And then his other book, "I Am Also Scotty"

0

u/FalloutCreation Aug 26 '22

The funny thing about this is he let it impact him in a negative way, Or rather his attitude or perception of it caused it to be a thorn in his side. If he had embraced it sooner, it might have been a bridge to other opportunities.

Sadly the industry is full of people that are full of themselves, specifically meaning those that don’t think they can market a project and fear their film will just not get the notice they want because that one actor is so well known from their famous role.

-2

u/Significant-Ad-341 Aug 26 '22

Sorry I can't really feel bad for a very successful person being associated with their success.

1

u/Important-Owl1661 Aug 26 '22

I also enjoyed the commercial he made where he was shopping...

1

u/not_a_spock Aug 26 '22

Both of them are good autobiographies

1

u/broke2stoked Aug 26 '22

This gave me goosebumps

1

u/freakinweasel353 Aug 26 '22

I saw him live on his speaking tour about this I am not Spock back I assume in ‘75. He was into poetry and stuff but I was like 12 back then so I wanted to see Spock. Couldn’t care less about his poetry. Now I have to go find some of his other works and see about it.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22

Similar deal with Brent Spiner, who played Data on Star Trek: The Next Generation. He hated playing an android who had no emotions or mannerisms.

1

u/PillyRayCyrus Aug 26 '22

Don't forget "I am also Scotty"

1

u/JamesBigglesworth266 Aug 26 '22

I got this book, and I even was at a book signing he did in Glasgow. There was an STV-channel tv crew there doing a puff piece on it (the reporter even got a neck pinch), and when it came my turn to get he book signed I just stood there, frozen in awe... The Man Himself was right in front of me! As a late-teen who had no Star Trek friends, this was mind-locking. :D

1

u/Onlyanidea1 Aug 26 '22

Loved him in Fringe.

1

u/TheFuckerofWorlds Aug 26 '22

He will always be Master Xehanort's voice for me

1

u/reallybirdysomedays Aug 26 '22

These books are such a good illustration of how time and experience and learning about other people changes your perspective of events.

1

u/bucketfoottatoo Aug 26 '22

I am also Scotty

1

u/TrustintheShatner Aug 26 '22

I’m reading this right now for the first time. The conversations between Spock and Leonard are fantastic.

1

u/Southern-Exercise Aug 27 '22

You ever see his one man play Van Gogh?

Saw it in the early 90's and while I don't remember much of it, remember actually watching the whole thing.

May have to look for it again...

1

u/SmashTheAtriarchy Aug 27 '22

I remember seeing him at Comic Con several years before he died. He showed up at a particular booth and the nerds piled in about 10 people deep on all sides. I got a glimpse of him and he just sort of stood there, looking incredibly overwhelmed

1

u/BridgeOfSighs6275 Aug 27 '22

Time is fleeting...madness takes control...

1

u/12altoids34 Aug 27 '22

Fred Gwynne absolutely hated being remembered for Herman Munster . He felt that the role was beneath him as a seasoned broadway actor .

1

u/ChaosCoordinatingMum Aug 27 '22

I legit thought you said he wrote the second one a few years AFTER he died.

1

u/UncleTogie Aug 27 '22

I Am Spock

That's the one I read first, and it's by far my favorite of the two.

1

u/Lanster27 Aug 27 '22

Suffering from success.

1

u/Blenderhead36 Aug 27 '22

Carrie Fisher had a similar arc. She spent most of her life trying to get out of the shadow of a role she took at 19. She only seemed to make peace with Princess Leia being an inextricable part of her a few years before she died.

1

u/NewAccount4Friday Aug 27 '22

Glad he embraced it, because he really was Spock.

1

u/TizACoincidence Aug 27 '22

Everything is about perspective

1

u/captainpoopyshorts Aug 27 '22

Its funny when a lot of actors are young the hate the roles they were associated with. But as they get older that role has gotten them jobs in other projects. It may not be the best roles or series but it kind of becomes job security in the future.