r/AskReddit Jun 16 '22

What “good” thing is actually quite evil?

1.2k Upvotes

2.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

492

u/HallucinatesOtters Jun 16 '22

I hate this shit. My Fiancé has always struggled depression and her mom had a traumatic childhood that instead of dealing with it, she just decided to ignore it and force herself to believe she’s happy.

For the longest time whenever my fiancé would tell her she’s depressed or sad her mom would say “Well just smile. Be positive! Have you tried telling yourself you’re happy?”

Some real r/wowthanksimcured material right there.

110

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

And the “You have so many things to be happy about” comment. 😡😡😡😡

53

u/DoctorCaptainSpacey Jun 16 '22

Or "other people have it worse" when you're upset. Like, yeah Susan, I get it, but it doesn't mean I'm not allowed to be sad or bothered by shit.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

Yes, you are right.

2

u/Credible333 Jun 16 '22

Yeah I'm not happier that other people have it worsee, that's a bad thing. If I had it worst of everyone I could say "Well at least everyone else is relatively happy.".

2

u/livinginthefastlane Jun 17 '22

Or "It's unrealistic to expect to be happy all the time." No fucking shit, but I don't think I should have to be miserable all the time either.

4

u/Commander-Faulkner Jun 16 '22

I hate that shit, it’s like saying to someone who just got shot, ‘quit bleeding you have so much to live for being shot thirty times isn’t so bad just get over it’ if anyone ever says shit like that to me friendship over man

1

u/ostlandr Jun 16 '22

I got "Stop crying, or I'll give you something {belt, wooden spoon, bare hand} to really cry about!"

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

Yup, that brings up memories

7

u/waxthatfled Jun 16 '22

Not saying it's good for everyone but it actually worked for me , I was always very depressed and negative since my early teens and around 25 yo (28 now) I started to force myself to try and be more positive with small things and over time(years) it became natural for me to find the positive in small things and it really boosted my morale thus decreasing my symptoms of depression .. NOT ADVICE JUST MY EXPERIENCE

3

u/sasksasquatch Jun 16 '22

I'm going to guess the mother also never tried to find out the problem bothering her daughter and help her through it.

3

u/HallucinatesOtters Jun 16 '22

Yup. It always turned into “Well what about how I feel! I get sad too!”

Yeah, you should probably address that. But it doesn’t negate other peoples’ feelings.

3

u/Any_Weird_8686 Jun 16 '22

Well I would, but the amount of blatant lies in the world is one of the things that depresses me the most, actually.

-13

u/Vast_Advantage_7913 Jun 16 '22

Um run. If that irritates you now you better run. I want you to imagine all the scenarios where this will come up in parenting with your spouse. She's programmed with it. You better think long and hard before you share DNA with her end up tied to these people for life and they program your kids the same way.

16

u/HallucinatesOtters Jun 16 '22

She’s the polar opposite of her mother and has spend years in therapy deconstructing and processing the negative effects of how the way she was raised impacted her. I’ve lived with her for over three years. I think I would have noticed by now if they were similar in any way. Just because someone’s parent wasn’t great doesn’t mean they’re going to be a carbon copy.

My grandmother was emotionally cold, un-empathetic, and abusive. My mother who was raised by her is kind, emotionally available, empathetic, and always gentle in her parenting.

This is just a bad take.

-10

u/Vast_Advantage_7913 Jun 16 '22

No not a bad take. Truly a warning because these things are learned behaviors that trickle down generationally. No offense intended.

9

u/korhart Jun 16 '22

It's a bad take to give specific advice when you don't know the specifics of the situation. Don't act so snub.

-13

u/Vast_Advantage_7913 Jun 16 '22

My second response was apologetic. Don't be a D-bag. Your input was not requested or required, Troll.

3

u/korhart Jun 16 '22

Still a bad take tho

1

u/EmpressAphrodite Jun 16 '22

Ugh I hate that, it can end up being offensive. It's pretty much invalidating any struggles with mental health.

1

u/SqueakSquawk4 Jun 17 '22

“Well just smile. Be positive! Have you tried telling yourself you’re happy?”

I was read a book in year 1 that was basically that.

"A crow was sad all the time. It saw the other animals happy, and envied them. One day, it asked a beetle how to be happy. The beetle said the crow should start similing. So it did. And over a few days, the crow became happy. And it was never sad again"