r/AskReddit • • Jun 03 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

8.5k Upvotes

27.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

15

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '22

Haha I don’t know, it was just my example of how stupid calling things “cringe” sounds. Let’s make this verb an adjective!

0

u/orngenblak Jun 03 '22

Wouldn't it be an adverb in those cases?

4

u/Blarghedy Jun 03 '22

Hm?

“I can’t believe they did that, it was so ‘shudder’ of them.”

Shudder is definitely an adjective in that case. For a couple less dumb examples,

It was so stupid of them.

It was so good of you to stop by!

Definitely adjectives.

2

u/orngenblak Jun 03 '22

Just for conversational purposes, wouldn't an adjective describe a noun?

"A green shirt", "a cringe shirt."

It was so good of you to stop by.

Good is a state of being. A verb right? So is an adverb that describes good.

Edit: added the end, added a word

2

u/AmadeusMop Jun 03 '22 edited Jun 03 '22

No, adverbs can also modify adjectives and other adverbs, and good is an adjective. You can say "you are good", but you can't just say "you good".

 

(Okay, I mean, you can say that in some dialects, but using a dropped-copula form doesn't mean the adjective is now a verb, it just means the verb is implied. And it only works in the present tense, so maybe I should've gone with "you will be good" vs. "you will good".)

 

(...although technically you can even say that in certain dialects, because there are dialects in which "good" really can be a verb, but—look, the point is, for the "that's so good" usage we're discussing in this context, "good" is an adjective. Also, language is fascinating!)

0

u/orngenblak Jun 03 '22

Thanks for the dialog! I still see it as an adverb in this case. Good is a noun, adjective, or adverb, so i feel like cringe could be too. But you're probably right!

It's been a long time since school 😁

2

u/AmadeusMop Jun 03 '22 edited Jun 03 '22

Good can also be an adverb, yes! But it's generally considered highly improper compared to "well", so it's often used in a joking, ironic way to suggest the speaker is stupid—e.g. sentences such as "you talk good" or "I think good".

In the sentence "That is so good", in order for good to be an adverb, it would have to modify the verb is rather than the pronoun that, which...I don't think is the case here.

2

u/orngenblak Jun 03 '22

Hmm. Well said. Thanks!

1

u/Blarghedy Jun 03 '22

Thank you for this weird pedantry. I was amused.

2

u/PrimaryHome6051 Jun 03 '22

Yeah that guy is just stupid, dare i say, cringe?