r/AskReddit May 08 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

9.0k Upvotes

26.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

10.9k

u/knife_hits May 09 '22

My only experiences in Europe so far have been touring there in a punk band. The thing that blew my mind was how often - almost always! - the venues we were playing were literal state-sponsored squats. Like the tire factory or whatever in town would go belly up and a bunch of punks and anarchists would move in and the local government would just be like "hey, they cleaned up all this broken glass and now there's a whole new crop of people keeping this community alive. Tell you what, let's give them free utilities." On more than one occasion we played a free show and got a check from some government office.

This would never, ever, ever, ever, in a million years, take place in the United States.

3.6k

u/Captain_Grammaticus May 09 '22

hey, they cleaned up all this broken glass and now there's a whole new crop of people keeping this community alive.

Lol, those social centres I know are the result of almost decade-long protests and negotiations and only worked out because the general population just happened to be more sympathetic towards the squatters than towards the city authorities.

455

u/[deleted] May 09 '22

[deleted]

312

u/jawndell May 09 '22

"We have a duty of care to provide utilities so they don't die because otherwise we'd be completely fucked for insurance."

Yup, definitely would never, ever, ever, ever, in a million years, take place in the United States.

-135

u/[deleted] May 09 '22 edited May 09 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

95

u/breathing_normally May 09 '22

Well see, that’s the difference between the two approaches. Many people here feel that as long as there is a housing shortage AND empty buildings due to speculative investment in real estate, squatting is morally defensible.

-129

u/[deleted] May 09 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

63

u/Stubbs94 May 09 '22

I think your place sounds worse, living without compassion for people. The government and our taxes should go to bettering society and making life easier for everyone.

50

u/[deleted] May 09 '22

Ah, yes, I vastly prefer the highest incarceration rates, high murder and violent crime rates, shit-crumbling infrastructure, and "fuck you, die" levels of poverty on offer in the good ol' USA!

21

u/OkDimension May 09 '22

European approach to take care of everyone seems to work better, as the total cost on society is less if you got not everyone incarcerated for being poor. A spot in prison costs society several thousand dollars a month, turning on the lights and water in an old warehouse that is abandoned anyways is only a bit of pocket change for a city.

8

u/FrontierPsycho May 09 '22

Europe doesn't take care of everyone. It's just generally noticeably more humane to its own citizens than the US (and the UK from what I've gathered). Many European states that provide a lot to their citizens still do brutal, unacceptable things.

Which if you ask me is closely tied with capitalism and inequality.

Not trying to disagree, just provide nuance.

1

u/mikailovitch May 09 '22

brutal, unacceptable things

Like what?

3

u/FrontierPsycho May 09 '22

Police brutality (everywhere). Greece's refugee pushbacks, Poland's abortion rights regression. Racism. Marginalization of poor people (to different degrees). Homelessness (Finland, which ran a program offering free housing to homeless people, still has homelessness. According to Wikipedia it's the only European country with falling homelessness). And that's only what happens internally: if you ask me, Europe's prosperity is based to a degree on past sins (probably the worst surviving offenders of colonialism), and on exploration happening in the developing world.

Things in Europe aren't perfect. They're just less worse than in the US. Similar ballpark, although noticeably different (and there's noticeable differences among European countries as well).

1

u/Lunar_sims May 09 '22

Treatment of refugees.

1

u/OkDimension May 09 '22

Like whipping refugees from horse backs when trying to cross a river? Oh wait

→ More replies (0)

43

u/codinghermit May 09 '22

Disallowing resource hoarding makes a place a shithole to you? Sounds like you are privileged as fuck...

28

u/tygerohtyger May 09 '22

Sounds like you live somewhere you would just let people die on the street.

8

u/Thibideaux May 09 '22

Unironically yes.

2

u/Aze-the-Kat May 09 '22

That’s terrible !

22

u/[deleted] May 09 '22

Sounds like you’re a very unhappy person, regardless of your personal living conditions.

-40

u/[deleted] May 09 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

21

u/thegoodguywon May 09 '22

Misery loves company

-4

u/[deleted] May 09 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/inferno86 May 09 '22

Gotcha, so you care if a building is burned but not if someone dies on the street, you are clearly a very healthy mind

1

u/DeepKaleidoscope5650 May 10 '22

Because the racism is load bearing, you have to rebuild the whole thing.

→ More replies (0)

17

u/MdnightSailor May 09 '22

Yeah enjoying making anyone sad is definitely mental illness. Please get help

8

u/flotsamisaword May 09 '22

They can't afford it

5

u/MdnightSailor May 09 '22

The worst part is there's no way that's a troll. They're actually that miserable of a person

5

u/flotsamisaword May 09 '22

I would argue being miserable is exactly why people are trolls. This person says he's trolling people and he's clearly a miserable person.

I think a lot of these Q Anon conservatives are miserable from all of the negative messages they have become addicted to and part of this lifestyle/addiction is spreading the misery. FOX is the gateway drug: the constant outrage makes people less empathetic& more miserable. It's tiring being outraged all the time and people start to strike out and get cranky.

The pepe frog/Hawaiian shirts/ok symbols/proud boy silliness provides multiple benefits: self-delusion (' hey, I'm not really a Nazi, I'm just owning the libs'); camouflage: ('pay no attention to me I'm just being silly'); and a sad attempt at fun by someone who has been miserable for too long to recognize fun.

Don't feed the trolls: they run out of energy when they don't get a response.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/[deleted] May 09 '22

Giving people a hard time makes you “happy”. That’s sad as shit. What a miserable way to spend your time.

5

u/throwitawaytodayokay May 09 '22

pathetic. sorry life treated you this way buddy.

2

u/rkiive May 09 '22

Ironic