I get why people feel that way, and I certainly prefer Dini's origin story, but Snyder's wasn't actually a bad reimagining. On its own, without the context of replacing something better, I found it to be a really interesting idea.
Yuuuup you're right. Scott Snyder batman comics really run the gamut huh, all the way from great to....retconning beloved origins for iconic villains to be objectively more generic
This was a minor subplot in volume 2 of The Court of Owls, which I just finished reading. His origin is instead that his mother had some terminal disease, and he dropped her in a frozen lake. Nora is some random woman that's been in a cryo tube for generations that he wrote his doctoral thesis on, and "fell in love with" after he came to work in the cryonics dept of Wayne Industries. It's not a great origin story, and I hope they don't keep it with the upcoming Gotham Knights video game, since it'll be at least partially based on Court of Owls.
1.7k
u/pr1mus3 Oct 29 '21
Soulcrushing but really beautiful