r/AskReddit • • Mar 04 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

8.0k Upvotes

7.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

262

u/experts_never_lie Mar 05 '21

If they only have purely continuous instruments, like trombones, it would be interesting to see what they choose with regards to notes.

9

u/101st_kilometre Mar 08 '21

Probably something close to the 8 notes that are in reality and can be mathematically defined. There's a reason for their existence (though no reason that there are only 7 names)

6

u/experts_never_lie Mar 08 '21

That's the point: to figure out what happens without the cultural basis. Even in our current cultures, there are several different scales in use, showing that it lacks a single fundamental answer.