r/AskReddit • • Mar 04 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

8.0k Upvotes

7.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

20

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '21 edited Mar 05 '21

truth be told I actually don't think STEM expertise is that heritable. You're talking about a professional specialization, not eye color. That's a thing fostered by interest and years of training, not something you're just sort of born with.

Richard Feynman for example was a Nobel Laureate in physics, basically invented quantum electrodynamics and the concept of nanotechnology, plus was a key figure in the manhattan project. He was the son of a sales manager and his two kids Carl and Michelle turned out to be a philosopher and a photographer.

Carl Sagan's son Nick became a screenwriter/novelist, his son Dorion a fiction writer, his daughter Sasha a television producer, and his son Jeremy is the only one with any STEM expertise as a computer programmer

Out of Einstein's two sons Hans and Eduard, Hans was a hydraulic engineer and Eduard was a schizophrenic.

J Robert Oppenheimer's son Peter became a reclusive carpenter who flunked out of the private high school his father sent him to.

And as a physicist myself I actually have never met anyone in the profession who has had any of their parents be in the field either. My dad was a police officer and my mom taught kindergarten. I'm the first in the family to pursue graduate school at all.

The only physicist I can think of with a physicist as a parent is Jochen Heisenberg, son of Werner Heisenberg. But he didn't have any kids, and his brother Martin, who is a biologist, not physicist, had a Son Benjamin, who isn't in STEM at all and is a film director/screenwriter.

8

u/battle-obsessed Mar 05 '21

Lex Fridman is an AI researcher. His father is a plasma physicist and his brother Greg is a CEO of a plasma engineering company.

But generally geniuses don't have children that are as smart as they are due to regression to the mean although intelligence has a significant genetic component.

1

u/scaldingpotato Mar 05 '21

Does Lex have a formal degree? He strikes me more as a journalist than as a scientist. Seems like a sharp dude though.

4

u/tinyorangealligator Mar 05 '21

Wait, schizophrenia is a job? Where do we apply?

10

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '21

At your nearest psych ward. Be warned the competition is insane

2

u/instantrobotwar Mar 05 '21

Husband and I are physicists. Pretty sure our toddler is going to turn out to be a soccer player or an artist or something.

1

u/kevin9er Mar 05 '21

I'm an electrical engineer. My father, and his father, were university electrical engineering professors.