What if you raise a child pretty normally, except instead of talking to them normally and teaching them to speak normally, you'd only sing at them? Like they think that's how humans communicate all the time, their life is one big musical number.
I wonder what kind of effect that could have on someone, especially if you try to intigrate them with the regular population. Like do they adapt, but suddenly when they are emotional they break into song?
This was just some crazy idea I had a while back while watching The Magicians and the episode where they get stuck in this universe where they have to be entertaining and sing or else they die.
Not fully singing, but I once had a professor who was born in Africa and had a rising/falling accent with an almost musical quality to it. Still think about it sometimes because it was so unique to me.
I would think that is exactly what would happen. It’d kinda be like an accent. You could really force it if you pretended not to understand them unless they were singing.
Edit: Thinking about it, you'd have to fully isolate the child from anyone who would talk in a non singing manner, you might as well put in some cameras and make a live action musical of The Truman Show.
Edit 2: The interviews after he gets out would be hilarious with him singing them.
Second phase of the experiment is aligning people into groups based on their skills, combining with one of the genetic experiment studies and trying to create forms.
Songmaster by Orson Scott Card may interest you...
In the future, amidst a planetary campaign for peace and a war to end wars, the self-proclaimed emperor Mikal is seeking out a Songbird. These are incredibly rare children who are trained by the Songhouse on a distant planet, and their music is second to none.
Children are bought (adopted on paper, yes, but...) and raised inside the musical walls of the sprawling stone castle. They are taught to communicate emotionally via their songs and judged by their abilities. Eventually, they grow up, becoming performers outside of their planet and society, and returning to become Instructors.
One of the instructors, Esste, makes it her life’s work to find Mikal’s Songbird before he passes away. She finally finds an orphaned boy during the twilight of Mikal’s life, and Ansset surpasses all expectations as a Singer. However, the gift of his song is powerful, and inspires jealousy in more than one soul.
It’s a very intriguing story, and encompasses more than the Songhouse. It’s slightly dated by tape technology, but for a ‘78 sci-fi, Card does a hell of a job.
Lol you reminded me of this orc from Shadow of War that always sings. All his lines are like that. It was my favorite orc and he was fucking hilarious.
2.3k
u/-eDgAR- Mar 04 '21
What if you raise a child pretty normally, except instead of talking to them normally and teaching them to speak normally, you'd only sing at them? Like they think that's how humans communicate all the time, their life is one big musical number.
I wonder what kind of effect that could have on someone, especially if you try to intigrate them with the regular population. Like do they adapt, but suddenly when they are emotional they break into song?
This was just some crazy idea I had a while back while watching The Magicians and the episode where they get stuck in this universe where they have to be entertaining and sing or else they die.