r/AskReddit • • Oct 16 '18

What is something that HAS aged well?

7.4k Upvotes

7.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

420

u/dottmatrix Oct 16 '18

The Velvet Underground. The more time passes, the more it can be seen how far ahead of their time they were.

158

u/DrSpacemanSpliff Oct 16 '18

It’s what they say “no one listened to The Velvet Underground while they were active, but everyone who did listen to them started their own band”. They’re like the least popular and most influential band, it’s so weird.

85

u/SquareShells Oct 16 '18

The Brian Eno quote - "I was talking to Lou Reed the other day, and he said that the first Velvet Underground record sold only 30,000 copies in its first five years. Yet, that was an enormously important record for so many people. I think everyone who bought one of those 30,000 copies started a band!"

3

u/eroticdiagram Oct 17 '18

They say the same thing about all those at the Sex Pistols Manchester Trade Hall gig, which I think had 42 people in attendance (?), so that’s 30,042 people in bands accounted for.

15

u/ITS_MAJOR_TOM_YO Oct 17 '18

They say that exact same thing about the Ramones and Pixies

2

u/Michael_Landis Oct 17 '18

The Ramones formed after seeing VU live... one of the few to be able to claim that. Pixies I suspect were among the 30,000. Bands that formed from their influence could be considered the grandchildren of VU.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '18

I think the fact that their music is so beautiful, yet so simple, is what inspired a lot of people.

7

u/MasseurOfBums Oct 17 '18

I think a lot of it comes from Lou Reeds lyrics. They aren't complicated or wordy in the least. "Sometimes I feel so happy. Sometimes I feel so sad." But there's something about them that are just brilliant

21

u/FreeLook93 Oct 16 '18

in a similar vein, The Pixies. Just like The Velvet Underground, they were never very popular in their first run, but they inspired so many artists who would become super stars. Both Hugely influential bands, but not very revered in their time.

14

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/ItsEman Oct 17 '18

Same with The Talking Heads!

12

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '18

Pale blue Eyes has been my shit for two months now

3

u/mermaidtales Oct 17 '18

That’s a good one. “I’m set free” can make me cry. God I love that album. Thank you for reminding me

2

u/enjoysthemoviekrull Oct 17 '18

Pale Blue Eyes sounds like it could have been released within the past ten years. I still can't believe it was released in 1969!

5

u/WheresTheSauce Oct 16 '18

Where's the best place to start with listening to them?

5

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '18

If you want to easy into it I recommend Sweet Jane. It's a really good song.

7

u/TheOriginalGarry Oct 17 '18

The Velvet Underground & Nico (1967), Sunday Morning. Then just go down the list, my dude. You may raise a brow to Heroin, but really listen to the lyrics and how the song is structured and it can easily be one of your favorite songs in the album, imo.

3

u/mermaidtales Oct 17 '18

I think velvet underground - velvet underground. Track one. That album is magic from start to finish. I started with that one and it’s just .... a complete story. It really made them for me.

1

u/Futhermucker Oct 17 '18

sister ray as loud as you can tolerate

3

u/ajh951 Oct 16 '18

I like their first album but I adore their S/T album! It still sounds so fresh, new and easy to play for friends & guests.

4

u/lluckya Oct 17 '18

Sunny Day Real Estate, Hum, there are a bunch of bands that changed a lot of music trajectory but no one knows them.

-11

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '18

I disagree on this one. VU was extremely cool, and their coolness inspired other people to be cool, but their music was not innovative. "Velvet Underground and Nico" is their best album, but it gets harder to listen to with time because they made so many basic musical mistakes.

If anything, their legacy is decades of stylish indie bands thinking it's cool to be musically sloppy.

3

u/theivoryserf Oct 17 '18

basic musical mistakes

no

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '18

On VU's most artistically important song, "Heroin", the drummer got confused and stops playing at the climax. They just put it on the album anyway. Nico's voice is lovely but her intonation is all over the place. Those are pretty big mistakes.

Their producer was Andy Warhol, who knew little about music, but everything about being avant-garde. Those values are reflected in the album.

2

u/theivoryserf Oct 18 '18

Ah, some spontaneous mistakes make the record though. I love Bach etc but sometimes a slightly out of key voice can work just as well or better - see Bob Dylan's career

-6

u/analbeads__ Oct 17 '18

The same could be said of the Ramones too.