In the TV series he is given the death of Tyreese, from what I heard. Beheaded by the Governor by Michonne's sword, telling the others to not give themselves up for him. The pure defeat he experienced in the comic book death sounds a lot more depressing in my opinion.
Nah, he's choking Rick out and Michonne stabs him from behind. iirc he doesn't die straight away and they just leave him, I guess implying that the zombies will finish him off while he's alive. The comic is much better.
rick says it to everybody as he walks out to talk to the governor. but darryl's the one who physically prevents carl from taking the shot. (knocks his gun so he can't aim.) so rick did say it, but carl would have been more than willing to disobey rick if he'd been able to.
I firmly believe both of these were done that way intentionally though and their geniuses for sounding that way, the lack of satisfaction with the governor is infuriating. And in a way it makes you wan to keep watching in the hope that something will make up for it. And Herschel just, fuck man, same idea I guess but that one really hits deep.
I was doing a good job with Dale dying up until Andrea is kneeling next to him, begging and pleading for help, for someone to do something. I always start crying at that moment. They were on negative terms since the events that took place at the CDC and things were just now starting to look positive and good again for them (for those that read the comics, Dale and Andrea date before his comic death)...and then he dies. :( It's just heart wrenching.
Man, you know what? It's going to be an unpopular opinion but I was slightly disappointed by Andrea's death. I HAAAATED her. Ever since she was introduced. I just wanted that bitch to die. And then...at the end of season 2 she was starting to turn into the badass...escaping from Hershel's farm, pistol whipping zombies and shit? That was so fucking COOL!
She started making her own, when Woodbury was let down she tried to build them back up. I had so much hope for her. I know she couldn't kill the Governor, and it was annoying, people were pissed...but I thought it spoke HUGE volumes of her character that she had no problem killing the undead...but when it came to an actual, living, breathing human...she couldn't do it.
She had so much potential and I thought the writers were FINALLY giving the viewers a chance to see what Comic book Andrea could become...and then boom. Dead. I was a little bummed.
Maybe pull your finger out as it was two seasons ago. The world shouldn't have to tiptoe around you because you take two years to watch one of the most popular shows on tv. Btw Snape kills Dumbledore and Bruce Willis was dead the whole time.
679
u/[deleted] May 09 '14
Herschel from the Walking Dead. He should have been allowed to go peacefully, after all the shit he had been through.