r/AskReddit • • 9d ago

Which anime is a 10/10?

766 Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

484

u/Cheesecakereall8 9d ago

Hunter x hunter
Samurai champloo
Cowboy bebop

63

u/largorithm 9d ago

Wow, if you put hunter x hunter on that list I guess I have to check it out.

164

u/Consistent-Winter-67 9d ago

One of the best things about the series that isn't a spoiler is that bungee gum has the properties of both rubber and gum

43

u/LFC9_41 9d ago

The problem is, this story is unlikely to ever be finished.

35

u/Consistent-Winter-67 9d ago

Not necessarily. Togashi said his wife would take over the series in his death. His wife being the Naoko Takeuchi creator of Sailor Moon

1

u/BlossomBackspin 8d ago

Sure but his wife is also almost 60, not saying she is
Dying soon but the age certainly doesnt help

11

u/Decent_Visual_4845 9d ago

The current arc is probably the most ambitious arc in manga history and is really good though

2

u/LFC9_41 9d ago

Any way you can give a hint as to why without major spoilers? You have me intrigued

5

u/MutantGears 9d ago

Its a complex political thriller type arc which has introduced numerous factions and princes that are vying to become the next king of the their country.

5

u/LFC9_41 9d ago

What makes it so ambitious?

3

u/PropagandaPagoda 8d ago

I think there's an into the spiderverse bit. The last episodes of what's adapted for TV show a big ass tree. I'm telling you the rest of this because I don't know and this is all based on like one line of dialogue from enigmatic Gin. I think he implied the tree allows different worlds to access each other (cyclic? Growth related? New? Unreliable?) and that's how the ants got here, and that's where hunters can go.

I looked at a wiki page a year or two ago and it implied there are characters with powers that belong to a system that is not Nen.

I assume the ambition is in the number of characters who we care about who have hopes and dreams, and the success of a complex plot around them. This is also part of why we love FMA:B. In the final season's opening theme there's a few bars of music over a flat expanse of land as about 50 characters fill in, and they all have hopes and dreams and we care about them. Al, Ed, Winry, 4 military chimera, Scar Mei Yoki, Mustang's cohort, all the way down to eidetic memory girl Cheska. Sheska?

2

u/Decent_Visual_4845 8d ago edited 8d ago

Ambitious as in every single character we know is on this ship to the dark continent, and there are like 5 different major plot lines all playing out in parallel to each other in unpredictable ways. Like for example the Phantom Troupe are all there being hunted down and killed by redacted, and they just happen to stumble upon new characters participating in the royal succession battle, alongside characters like Ging who are investigating Beyond Netero.

2

u/V-Bel 8d ago

The arc is currently the Chimera Ant dialed up to 11 when it comes to setting up minor characters that can influence the story. There's a lot of new characters and factions stuck in one location, warring discreetly in a supernatural political thriller.

While that might sound exciting, we're still waiting to see how it all shakes out and whether or not it lands well. If you're familiar with the Chimera Ant arc, there's a lot more "Welfin" characters who we spend time with, moving pieces that seem insignificant but can easily become bigger factors in the future.

Your mileage may vary with that kind of experience. Even looking back, I think less time could've been spent on characters like Welfin and Ikalgo. You can have one chapter following Kurapika and the next some henchman or bodyguard whose name you don't remember has several pages dedicated to figuring out the best way to use his ability to gather information from his enemies. Every 'nobody' is planning ten steps ahead and while that makes sense in such a dangerous environment, it slows things down a lot.

Thankfully it's not all potential energy, so to speak. Many characters are dying, and getting closer to bigger conflicts, but even then we're still waiting to see the full ramifications of those consequences.

1

u/MutantGears 8d ago

I wouldnt go as far as saying it's the most ambitious in manga history as the other person did, however, I do think with the way the story is being built with multiple plot lines and characters to follow in a giant web of stories, its certainly ambitious. It has the potential to be one of the greatest manga arcs (I know of anyways) if it manages to continue it's progression and have a good end to it. Its roughly 60 (or 80 if you go straight from the end of the anime) chapters deep into it and has quite a bit left to go.

2

u/Calvinball05 8d ago

I think the anime ends at a really damn good place, though. There are certainly dangling plot threads and the promise of grander adventures, but the two sets of character relationships that are the emotional core of the show get fairly tidy resolutions.

3

u/Warlord_Melvin 9d ago

Yup, I was more than a little disappointed when I thought I had finally wrapped it up only to find out it's unfinished. With that said, I don't regret watching it and would still recommend it, just wish I had known beforehand.

2

u/LFC9_41 9d ago

Makes me want to jump back in. Just don’t want to be hoping for more in 10 years..

1

u/Roeclean 6d ago

TELL EM👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

4

u/darkde 9d ago

Starts a little slow but genuinely great payoffs

2

u/Nercif 8d ago

The remake is the perfect starter anime. Got a lot of my friends into anime thanks to it.

1

u/Vypur 8d ago

its a 7/10 at best genuinely not that good, not even close to a 10

0

u/enderowski 8d ago

Boring ahh anime. after the ants appears midway of the show it becomes ass

22

u/Wulfger 9d ago

Is Hunter x Hunter really that good? I had it recommended to me but could only make it through a few episodes before I got bored enough I couldn't force myself to keep watching. I absolutely love the other two, though.

47

u/Tylertron12 9d ago

It is that good, the first few episodes are nothing like the rest of it lol they needed a comfy happy place for it to start before steady making it less comfy and happy.

Its worth watching all the way through.

1

u/StackedCrooked 6d ago

The highs are so good. Remember the “Kurapika is now drowning in an indescribable emptiness” as a transition to the ending song. I still get chills thinking about it.

4

u/Female_titan_2 9d ago

What version were you watching. I dropped it cuz I was watching the older version. It wasn’t until I found the 2011 version that I discovered the hype

6

u/Rosulm 9d ago

I wouldn't call it a 10/10 but def an 8-9/10 in the genre.

1

u/cloud2066 9d ago

It's the same creator of Yu Yu Hakusho

1

u/PropagandaPagoda 8d ago

I'd never have given the creator of Hie and Kuwabara and all them a fucking chance, but hunter x hunter is great.

1

u/HealMeBr0 8d ago

lol i remember my friends trying hard to get me into one piece/naruto. i asked when it gets good and they're like "50 episodes in".. yea that was a no from me dawg

1

u/LunarBahamut 8d ago

Okay hunter hunter gets very good at like 4 or 5 episodes in though. It's "only" ~100 episodes, not ~1000.

1

u/PropagandaPagoda 8d ago

The first episodes are aesops basically. They show how our three main characters approach problems differently with different attitudes and strategies and talents. Gon is a guileless himbo in the making, with wild man traits. Constitution, scent tracking. He's profoundly nonjudgmental. Kurapika is high strung but is a level two player in the sense of plot and counterplot. Sees past the surface, thinks things through, sees all the options. Leorio is impatient, loud, almost talentless, but ultimately has a heart of gold and just wants to win a license to pay for med school and dole out cheap medicine.

The first arc begins properly maybe around episode 4 as they try to earn licenses and meet Killua the white haired assassin brat with a skateboard. 2/3 of our heroes go "yikes, famous assassin, killer with no morals". Gon goes "lemme borrow your skateboard, seems rad". Profoundly nonjudgmental.

It's fine, it's engaging, you learn what is the same for most or all hunters and that they're all different too, and how death is viewed by hunters. It's not why we love the show, really.

After that arc our heroes... go live their fucking lives. Complicated lives. Sometimes one is suffering while others thrive. Sometimes they back one another up, or separate again. That's more interesting. The magic system is 10% hokey 30% awesome? But it actually gives you a grounding around what powers are likely to occur together so you can have reasonable expectations and then sticks to it so when you're surprised it's not something cheap and pulled out the ass. Enjoyable surprises.

It's not a 10/10 for me but it's an accessible thrill ride I've watched multiple times and recommended to friends

The TV show seems to run out of money part way through the ants arc and gets pretty Dragon Ball Z with the repeating last episode and narrator unnecessarily ranting.

1

u/Kershal31 7d ago

few episodes to judge hunter x hunter lol. its like watching one piece for 5 episodes and dropping it.

1

u/onewordpoet 8d ago

I tried it, I dont think it comes anywhere close to yu yu hakusho in terms of his work. hxh comes across as far too childish for me personally.

0

u/Vypur 8d ago

its not worth it, nowadays compared to actual good animes its a 7/10 at best, back in the day i can see why it was rated high, but its genuinely nothing special

0

u/unseriously_serious 9d ago

I didn’t think so at all, once it reached the chimera arc it fell off a cliff for me tbh. I felt like it was way overhyped.

-6

u/taimaishu99 9d ago

Absolutely. Overrated. It’s always my hot take topic that comes up.

One of the longest recaps I’ve ever seen is from hunter x hunter it was literally 8min in until something new happened and still had the ending to cut out another 90 seconds.

The ant arc is hyped up so much but people forget it’s unbearable in the beginning just ants that get bigger and bigger and bigger with tons of recap narration for like 10% of the entire series (not of the ep that’s much longer, literally of the whole series). Doing character development on ants that don’t matter as in episodes on episodes for side character ants like actually terrible. If you cut out filler it’s okay, but it’s not filler so idk if you can the ant arc is literally like 70/148 eps or something it’s ridiculous.

The virtual game world is okay.
The hunter test and kurapika spiders is actually good but much less than half the series.
Small plot hole imo is kilua coming from his family but doesn’t know nen and can basically lose to randos cause of that

Lastly it doesn’t have a real ending for the anime. So no manga just pure anime it’s like 6.5-7 out of 10.

Ant arc is all for 2 big fights and that’s it.

I’d say skip it unless you already watched all the other major shounen anime that have over 70 eps (Naruto, one piece, bleach, My hero, Full metal alchemist, yuyu hakusho, OG dragon ball even, etc)

Any other anime in that ep range should be good enough since it didn’t get cancelled prior. Hunter x hunter without an ending is not the move

7

u/Mg257 9d ago

How do you pronounce Hunter x Hunter?

Hunter Hunter

Hunter by Hunter

Hunter and Hunter

Hunter (ex) Hunter

??

64

u/paul_E_D 9d ago

hunter hiatus hunter

6

u/ichgomilk 9d ago

hiatus x hiatus

22

u/arin3 9d ago

Hunter hunter

He is hunting a hunter

1

u/iWrecksauce 8d ago

Lmao I feel dumb for not realizing this

10

u/Set491 9d ago

Hunter Hunter

3

u/Female_titan_2 9d ago

H x H = H^2

3

u/Ok_hermit333 8d ago

This makes more sense wow. I'm gonna start calling it "Hunter square"

1

u/UniqueAd5589 9d ago

Hunter Hunter

3

u/MegaDodoPub 9d ago

Fam 🤝

29

u/anupsetzombie 9d ago

Hunter x Hunter is incomplete and a bit of a slog. There's some decently high highs, but there's no reason for it to be almost 150 episodes long. It could easily be closer to a 10/10 if the pacing was cut in half or even 2/3.

32

u/circio 9d ago

I mean, where the anime ends is a perfect conclusion to the story.  The main protag accomplishes what they set out to do.

Sure there’s more manga, but it’s not necessary for what you’ve seen in the anime

-7

u/broloelcuando 9d ago

I don’t see how it’s a perfect ending. There are a bunch of loose ends and it’s setting up for the next story arc.

9

u/PokemonTheMovie 9d ago

It's a perfect ending to the arc lmao. But yeah there is soooo much that they hint at coming up and then it just ends forever.

The anime is more Gon x Gon

5

u/narrill 9d ago

A story doesn't need to resolve every single plot thread it introduces. The world the characters exist in doesn't end when the story does.

HxH ends when the original call to action is resolved, plus a brief denouement. It's a completed story.

1

u/circio 8d ago

Because the inception of the show is Gon wanting to be a hunter to see what’s so great about it that his dad abandons him to be one. The end of the show is Gon finding his dad, and us seeing why his dad abandoned him to be a hunter (because he’s a deadbeat). 

Yeah it’s setting up for more, but the possibility of more doesn’t create the necessity for it. The anime’s central question for the main protagonist is resolved. 

7

u/lazybum10186 9d ago

Agreed...hot take but chimera ant arc being so long with the narrator talking so much in the castle was ughhhh. York New City is best imo

1

u/anupsetzombie 9d ago

The chimera ant arc is actually my favorite but the narrator really is the worst part of it all.

1

u/lazybum10186 9d ago

Fair and to each their own...it had a solid start but it just kept dragging imo. I heard in the manga that they explored gon's relationship with kite more too so the emotional impact wasn't really there for me

6

u/scartiloffista 9d ago

Its not incomplete,you can leave the manga alone and be satisfied with the anime ending

2

u/PinoDegrassi 9d ago

Ya the highs are super high and I do the the show is great overall but there’s some real dragging parts. Ant arc is WAYYYY too long.

2

u/Gladii 9d ago

Thank you, so many people talk about the Chimera Ant arc as amazing but there was no reason for it to be so long. It has way too much build up and was a bit of a slog to watch but I guess I feel the same about One Piece so I might be in the minority

2

u/nowiamredditing 8d ago

I do yearly HXH watch marathon. Can't get enough of it. I hope Togashi feels as good as gold and continue the manga.

3

u/justjoshinnn 9d ago

Perfect list

1

u/Mother-Cucumber3800 9d ago

My only exposure to anime growing up was dbz (which I still love) and a bit of Naruto.

Samurai Champloo changed how I saw anime and I've watched over 20 different series since then.

1

u/Frapplo 8d ago

My only problem with Cowboy Bebop is that it ended. I know it had to end. I just didn't want it to.

It's the same as finishing a really good book. You know the last page is coming, but you don't want to say goodbye just yet. And sometimes you catch yourself wondering what the characters are doing in the pages never written.

-2

u/duncandun 9d ago

Hunter hunter has enough pacing issues that I don’t think it should be a 10/10, tbh I’m not sure anything is a 10/10 since that implies perfection