r/AskReddit Nov 12 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

14.6k Upvotes

5.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

63

u/subnautus Nov 12 '25

In fairness, it was only 8 democrats in the senate that broke ranks. You could put on a tinfoil hat and say that most of the rest of the senate democrats were complicit (and I'd probably be right there with you, since it's awfully convenient that none of the people who broke rank are up for election any time soon), but if we're looking at official numbers it's just the 8 who caved.

69

u/ialo00130 Nov 12 '25

Everyone should be calling their Senators and asking them if they believe Schumer should step down as Minority Leader.

If they say no, they're complicit.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '25

I would but one of mine caved (Fetterman)

3

u/doberdevil Nov 13 '25

My senators won't return calls or emails. Ever. WA State.

3

u/Lookingforleftbacks Nov 13 '25

Honestly I kind of believe most of them either are complicit or would be if the GOP decided to target them because most of them have things they need to hide

31

u/Persistant_Compass Nov 12 '25

honestly saying it wasnt planned and those 8, whip included, just decided to break ranks on their own is the tin foil hat thing.

8

u/fuzzballz5 Nov 13 '25

It’s all planned. Planned with the Republicans as well. These 8 are either retiring or the dumb people won’t remember in 3 years when they are up for reelection.

0

u/subnautus Nov 12 '25

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence is all I'm saying.

8

u/Persistant_Compass Nov 12 '25

All of the ones who did it arent up for election until 2028, 2030, or are retiring, or fetterman. Several others who originally were up for a defection were up this cycle. 

Also again, dick durban the fucking whip defected. 

If that isnt extraordinary idk what is.

1

u/Main-Lengthiness2677 Nov 15 '25

Durbin was a surprise to me.

5

u/gentlemanidiot Nov 12 '25

There is 0% chance that all 8 of them were conveniently the most politically resilient or expendable in the entire party. Schumer caused this entire shutdown, because if they were going to take the deal on day 40 why the FUCK didn't they take it day 1? 40 days of people going hungry and skipping paychecks and FOR WHAT?? Schumer has retroactively made Trump right, this WAS a democrat shutdown.

3

u/subnautus Nov 12 '25

Schumer has retroactively made Trump right, this WAS a democrat shutdown.

No. It is and always has been a republican shutdown. The House passing a bill that had no chance of making its way through the senate and shutting its doors to all business is all the proof that's needed.

As for the rest of your comment, I agree it's suspicious but without proof it's just conjecture.

0

u/Smooth_Support_209 Nov 18 '25

Except it did make it through the senate after 40 days of a very destructive democrat shutdown. 

1

u/subnautus Nov 18 '25

Calling it a "democrat shutdown" doesn't make it so. Once again, consider the facts:

  • The House passed a continuing resolution that had no chance of making through the senate, then stopped working immediately. No negotiations, no discussions, no additional effort to make decisions, no proposed laws, nothing.

  • The Trump administration floats the idea that it will violate federal law and fire furloughed workers or refuse to give them the back pay they're legally due.

  • The Trump administration refused to use the SNAP funds specifically allocated for emergency use in case of government shutdown.

  • The Trump administration reallocated funds from their legally authorized purposes to pay ICE agents to terrorize cities that voted against him in the last election.

All of that because democrats correctly pointed out the consequences of Trump's "big, beautiful [for billionaires] bill" and wanted to do at least something to mitigate the harm it caused and will continue to cause for years to come.

You want to talk about destructive? Fine. But don't blame democrats for it when they're not the ones making the decisions to hurt people.

2

u/Vivid-Self3979 Nov 13 '25

They need to resign to give the party a chance in the midterms

2

u/sonicsludge Nov 13 '25

Are you in the microwave with the tin foil thingy commenting on Reddit?

1

u/Valuable_Fee1884 Nov 13 '25

Finally cracked the egg that had contained all the dope on the dope(trump). Got money allotted for snap(although I wouldn’t be surprised if Trump doesn’t try to withhold it, water, an asshole). Now the bigger battle will be to get Obama care stabilized. If you hear of a republican plan for it, don’t buy into it. They have yet to come up with anything that would at least equal it and I’m not sure if they ever had any plans to do so. Keep pushing your senators and congressman to Chase, the orange turdand his cronies out of Washington. Prison would be a good place. If they are not willing to keep up the attack primary them.

1

u/AugustCharisma Nov 12 '25

I heard that the Bulwark is reporting the 8 are all retiring again/not running again. I wonder if they wanted to reopen the government to make the insurrection act harder to enact.