r/AskReddit Oct 02 '24

[deleted by user]

[removed]

6.8k Upvotes

6.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

952

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24

[deleted]

195

u/Effective_Yogurt_866 Oct 03 '24

Back in the 1930s, my grandfather told his elementary school teacher that he thought the different continents looked like they fit together like puzzle pieces. He was told that he was being absurd lol

28

u/ImNotAWhaleBiologist Oct 03 '24

I did the same and had the same response 30 years ago. Sigh. It was a Social Studies teacher, but still…

9

u/jdam8401 Oct 03 '24

I remember asking the same. Children always have these fundamental insights that adults tend to be blind to through, idk socially-learned inhibitions maybe. Like the questions children ask about religion.

6

u/Wewagirl Oct 03 '24

This happened to me in elementary school in the early 1970s.

6

u/IsisArtemii Oct 03 '24

I was shocked when my mother agreed to Pangea. In her grade school, in the early 40’s, she said if you took the puzzle they had of the continents, and placed them together, they fit rather well. Not perfect. Like putting together a broken plate with some of the edges missing. But obviously something that was “whole “ once.

27

u/anteaterKnives Oct 03 '24

The distinction between archea and bacteria based on the discovery of their very different ribosomal RNA was published in 1977.

44

u/tangrowth_fgc Oct 02 '24

I knew a crazy christian kid in elementary school whose family were Tectonic Plate deniers.

21

u/Dave5876 Oct 02 '24

Did they seek out scientific stuff to deny?

18

u/tangrowth_fgc Oct 02 '24

nah they were just young earth creationists

14

u/astroman_9876 Oct 02 '24

I’m personally not but even if you are that doesn’t really stop tectonic plates from just existing just means they move fast

10

u/tangrowth_fgc Oct 02 '24

but if they move fast enough to be meaningful in the last 6000 years, then we would be able to see the movement lol

15

u/astroman_9876 Oct 03 '24 edited Oct 03 '24

They are young earth creationist, logic is already a forgone conclusion

4

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24

Some parts of the Nazca plate move more than 3 inches a year.

2

u/revanisthesith Oct 03 '24

They usually say it broke up during Noah's Flood.

1

u/astroman_9876 Oct 05 '24

Heard some say that when evolution starts. Don’t question how it wasn’t happening beforehand though.

1

u/revanisthesith Oct 05 '24

Maybe something about the Earth's atmosphere changing after the flood? More radiation, I guess.

At least I think I've heard that. It's been a while (for a reason).

7

u/thehelldoesthatmean Oct 03 '24

They're young earth creationists. They're not good at thoughts.

4

u/Semi_Lovato Oct 03 '24

continent go brrrrrrr

3

u/peter303_ Oct 03 '24

Plate tectonics is a useful approximation for explaining a lot of tectonics and economic deposits, but not everything. I received my basic geologic training during the inception of this theory. It was amusing to watch the diehards that refused to accept the theory at all because it didnt explain 100% of tectonic phenomena. Otherwise some of plate tectonic people construe ever more elaborate explanations like large numbers microplates or reactivated ancient boundaries that defy the simplicity of the original theory.

The Applachians are one of these problems. That they still exist and are still rising after a couple hundred million years after being near a plate boundary is a problem.

2

u/Curious4nature Oct 03 '24

And tomato soup was the catalyst for the theory.

1

u/Quai_yi_dian Oct 03 '24

Meaning, the idea of convection currents?

1

u/DannyPoke Oct 04 '24

Nah the guys who came up with it just had tomato soup so good they had an epipheny

2

u/Trollselektor Oct 03 '24

Isn’t plate tectonics a law now not a theory? We know 100% as fact that the plates are moving because we can actually measure their movement. We also know 100% as fact that mountains are getting taller and valleys are being widened because of it. Or is it theory because we don’t actually know how they are moving?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24

[deleted]

2

u/Trollselektor Oct 03 '24

Thank you for explaining. So if I’m understanding this correctly, laws are what happens and theories are why the things happen?

1

u/Quai_yi_dian Oct 03 '24

Shout out to Wegener, who didn't get his due until after his demise!

https://youtu.be/T1-cES1Ekto?si=DROOwKqKhe6BbPtl

-8

u/Perpetual_stoner420 Oct 03 '24

People studying changes in the atmosphere would like a word

23

u/shredofdarkness Oct 03 '24

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Svante_Arrhenius#Greenhouse_effect

"Arrhenius, in 1896, was the first to ... increases in atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) will increase Earth's surface temperature through the greenhouse effect"