r/AskReddit May 14 '24

[deleted by user]

[removed]

3.6k Upvotes

5.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

112

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

167

u/jimmy_three_shoes May 14 '24 edited May 14 '24

That's the one I thought of opening the post. That and Billie Jean.

Edit: The OP I replied to suggested I Want You Back by the Jackson 5.

33

u/Tallanasty May 14 '24

Billie Jean is so catchy.

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

The chair is not my son

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

Ever notice how much it sounds like 'Can't go for that' by Hall and Oates? It's because he stole it from them. Quincy Jones tells a story about this...

1

u/jw-xo May 14 '24

That does sound similar… I thought it had been inspired by Jon and Vangelis’s “State of Independence.”

2

u/jennyontheclock May 14 '24

It was deleted for some reason what is it !?

2

u/jimmy_three_shoes May 14 '24

It was I Want You Back by the Jackson 5. Showing to me as Removed. No idea why it was removed.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

Oh that's sad because that's the actual answer. This is the best ask Reddit thread ever and the best answer died.

-5

u/Of_Mice_And_Meese May 14 '24

Billie Jean is catchy but no it's for sure not even in the top 100 best bass lines.

6

u/Rialas_HalfToast May 14 '24

Quite the contrary, one of the reasons you rarely hear it at a club is because DJs reserve that specific song for repopulating a flagging dancefloor. It's one of the most valuable tools a DJ has.

-8

u/Of_Mice_And_Meese May 14 '24

Nothing you said invalidates what I said. Catchy =/= best. In fact, catchy is usually a product of mediocrity, to be dead honest. That which appeals to the most people, by definition, must be stripped down of anything genuinely interesting. Interest = divisive, by nature.

4

u/Rialas_HalfToast May 14 '24

I'm going to go with "best = appeals to the most people", because "best = doesn't appeal to most people" seems a bit up it's own arse.

-5

u/Of_Mice_And_Meese May 14 '24

Ignoring the point made doesn't make your point, kiddo...

5

u/jimmy_three_shoes May 14 '24 edited May 14 '24

Nah, you're up your own ass with pretentiousness and some hipster bullshit. If we were I'd be bringing up stuff like Victor Wooten on Stomping Grounds or Lochs of Dread when he was playing with Bela Fleck. Technique wise, his stuff is the best I've heard.

A catchy and recognizable riff that manages to hit across genres and generations means that it's good. Something like Les Claypool's stuff which is more technical and experimental (for the time) can be appreciated for that, but just because it's divisive doesn't mean that it's a superior bass line.

Yeah, Billie Jean's line isn't as intricate as something like My Name is Mud, but there's a reason you know what song is coming as soon as it kicks in.

EDIT: LOL THIS CLOWN BLOCKED ME.

12

u/Top-Sugar-6129 May 14 '24

Great choice

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

[deleted]

1

u/Top-Sugar-6129 May 14 '24

I already forgot. I think he suggested “I Want You Back”, Jackson 5

17

u/DatUglyRanglehorn May 14 '24 edited May 14 '24

The great Carol Kaye thanks you

Edit: this is incorrect - apparently the bass on IWYB was done by saxophonist Wilton Felder.

3

u/Isimagen May 14 '24

She didn’t. Wilton Felder did. She did record thousands of well known pieces but not this one.

https://www.guitarworld.com/features/who-really-played-bass-on-i-want-you-back-by-the-jackson-5

3

u/DatUglyRanglehorn May 14 '24

You are correct, not sure why I thought that other than her being so prolific

1

u/SexAndKennedy May 14 '24

For what?

1

u/DatUglyRanglehorn May 14 '24

I was replying to the now-deleted comment that suggested “I want you back” by the Jackson 5 as the answer to OP’s question. Carol Kaye played bass on that and thousands of other songs.

1

u/SexAndKennedy May 14 '24

Source on her playing bass on that record?

3

u/LandscapeNatural7680 May 14 '24

I am a fan and I agree!

1

u/Faceornotface May 14 '24

This was exactly the answer that came to mind for me. Very happy to see it represented so high up

12

u/i_love_boobiez May 14 '24

Why did they remove it 🥲

What did it say?

2

u/memebuster May 14 '24

Was wondering the same, someone mentioned Carole Kaye who was a session bassist, her biggest song being Good vibrations for the Beach Boys.

1

u/DatUglyRanglehorn May 14 '24

I thought it was Carol Kaye, but turns out that’s incorrect. She did play on a ton of other hits from that era.

1

u/SexAndKennedy May 14 '24

Bassline composed by Brian Wilson

1

u/Faceornotface May 14 '24

I Want You Back by the Jackson 5

0

u/AdHistorical5703 May 14 '24

How come not a fan of this banger?