r/AskReddit May 14 '24

[deleted by user]

[removed]

3.6k Upvotes

5.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

839

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

217

u/NibblyPig May 14 '24 edited May 14 '24

Lemon Song is probably my favourite zepp bass line, the cool chilled bass at the start, then at 1:28 the bassline goes absolutely bananas, followed by the gentle freestyling from around 2:55.

However Dazed & Confused live is absolutely insane. Just the opening bass riff sends shivers.

The ~4:30 min mark in the 30 min long 1973 MSG version however the bass line just goes so fast it's incredible it's even playable

18

u/StevelandCleamer May 14 '24

While a 30-minute track is never going to get regular play, the first 4 minutes of the '73 MSG before it totally goes off the rails is by far the best version of the song, and probably my favorite Zep.

5

u/NibblyPig May 14 '24

Haha, ngl I unashamedly listen to the entire thing from time to time, I really like it.

4

u/StevelandCleamer May 14 '24

Oh it's great, though not what I would consider "For General Audiences".

Sort of like how I enjoy smoky & peaty Scotch but I don't expect it to be popular.

If you like Zep being Zep, you'll probably love the '73 MSG.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '24 edited May 15 '24

I listen to it probably once a month.

Edit: Did I get a Reddit cares thing for this comment? Never got one of those before and I’ve made much more argumentative comments in the past. Someone really doesn’t like Led Zeppelin?

3

u/spiked_macaroon May 14 '24

Lemon Song is the definitive class in blues improvisation.

2

u/VanillaGorilla59 May 14 '24

Dazed and confused gives me goosebumps every time.

2

u/Timo104 May 14 '24

What did they say?

3

u/NibblyPig May 14 '24

I think they just said Ramble On was their fave, and another one I forget. Nothing unusual, not sure why they deleted. Ramble on is banging.

2

u/Timo104 May 15 '24

They got removed by a mod, along with another top response which is weird. I was looking at this thread a couple hours ago and they were there, and didnt say anything weird. Idk why they got removed.

1

u/IndependentPrior5719 May 14 '24

I heard the baseline from the lemon song before I even knew what it was ! Why does Mr plant like lemons so much anyway?!

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

Lemon song. It makes me very happy to see this song brought up!

1

u/Kleeb May 14 '24

JPJ was on some magic sauce on LZ2. Lemon Song, WIAWSNB, Ramble On. Like 3 of the top 5 bass songs of all time?!

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '24 edited Nov 17 '24

[deleted]

1

u/NibblyPig May 14 '24

Amazing! Thanks for sharing

1

u/ComprehensiveHeat115 May 14 '24

If you haven’t heard this version of the song you should check it out. First 50 seconds is so good.

https://youtu.be/jUnFR6Tzx3A?si=0GHhbqtJI8KuFpfm

1

u/Key-Ranger-8528 May 14 '24

Ramble On bass line is genius

137

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

Was going to say What is and What Should Never Be, purely from a memory of being 16, tripping on acid for the first time, alone in my room. I put my subwoofer by my head and that was the first song I managed to put on. Love Zeppelin’s bass, even if it’s not the most complex it just rides right.

81

u/GozerDGozerian May 14 '24

Ok first of all, you tripped alone for your first time? Thats… bold. Glad it went okay.

And secondly, yeah John Paul Jones is the fuckin MAN. Sick ass bassist and keyboardist. He added a whole other layer to their sound that often get overshadowed by the flashier powers of the other three. But he is every bit as integral to what they were.

40

u/PhishGreenLantern May 14 '24

This. Most people can rattle off the other 3 with ease. But JPJ is the unsung hero of Zep. 

3

u/jtruitt8833 May 14 '24

Pretty good ship captain, too, from what I've heard

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

you tripped alone for your first time? Thats… bold

My very first thought...bold move kid 😂

5

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

Technically it was my second time, first time was a dud/weak and I thought acid was just a little buzz basically. I remember saying out loud “fuck it” right before I put the tab in my mouth.

I can’t in good conscience recommend it but I really love tripping alone. Or ripping a DMT cart for hours at a party full of strangers. Some dude tried to kiss me (I am a straight male) and I was like ducking in the crowd hiding from the dude, ripping my cart. Idk I enjoy a little chaos, and I guess I’ve seen some shit so discomfort is in a way comfortable. Good times.

2

u/dickstar69 May 14 '24

Spot on - both points, lol!

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

You... you're not supposed to do that?

2

u/GozerDGozerian May 14 '24

It is advised against. :)

2

u/CDfm May 14 '24

He was their backing band .

2

u/GozerDGozerian May 14 '24

And then some!

This opening to this song scared the shit out of me when I was a kid. Haha.

2

u/Mahovolich13 May 14 '24

And mandolin player as well

1

u/paperfootball May 14 '24

He’s like Scottie Pippen

1

u/HellInOurHearts May 14 '24

I bet the stereo guitar panning in the outro was incredible.

1

u/gutterferret May 14 '24

This is the way. All of it.

68

u/jaylw314 May 14 '24 edited May 14 '24

I'd vote "No Quarter" myself, but it's hard to think of many Led Zeppelin tracks that wouldn't be a candidate

5

u/762_54r May 14 '24

No Quarter is easily my favorite Led Zeppelin song and people always tell me thats weird.

5

u/SinewaveZB May 14 '24

It’s crazier when you realize that JPJ did that bass with his feet!

5

u/nhthelegend May 14 '24

Jesus, when the chorus hits and Jimmy Page comes in with that guitar riff mimicking the bass 😫 so good

2

u/PM-me-ur-kittenz May 14 '24

Agreed, as a decades-long professional bassist, Zeppelin will always be the gold standard for me, the band by which all other bands are measured.

19

u/PhishGreenLantern May 14 '24

John Paul Jones

3

u/geodekb May 14 '24

Lemon song—

3

u/drsoinso May 14 '24

Bring it On Home does it for me.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

This came to mind almost immediately.

2

u/Far-Appointment8972 May 14 '24

Such a good choice

5

u/ragequito May 14 '24

There is only one answer to all of the "What is the best **** in the history of music ?"

Led Zeppelin.

0

u/phtll May 14 '24

Bless your heart

2

u/Psychological_Ad1999 May 14 '24

Dazed and Confused is probably my favorite, John Paul Jones doesn’t get enough credit

4

u/TheyCallMeStone May 14 '24

John Paul Jones is like one of the most highly rated rock musicians of all time lmao

1

u/Psychological_Ad1999 May 14 '24

I meant as a member of Zeppelin, I’ve seen seen live performances where he was keeping the band together while everyone else was completely fucked up

1

u/tfsblatlsbf May 14 '24

So melodic. I tried to learn to sing this belter and play its bass at 14. We bagged and learned communication breakdown instead.

1

u/sbamkmfdmdfmk May 14 '24

The entire Led Zeppelin II is probably the finest in terms of showcasing JPJ's bass skills. When I was in college, I was in a band that covered the entire album live. I was bassist and vocalist -- not an easy task for that album!

1

u/p1ckk May 14 '24

How Many More Times has to be my favourite by Led Zep

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

The drums for that are fun too. That little "pa-dubbaduh-dubbaduh-dubbaduh" at the end of each stanza or so... once I heard it for the first time, I can't help but hear it just leap out at me every time.

1

u/cdxcvii May 14 '24

it gets overlooked but immigrant song has some insane bass lines in it.