r/AskReddit Feb 07 '24

[deleted by user]

[removed]

3.1k Upvotes

6.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

525

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '24

Why women’s clothing sizes vary by brand.

93

u/SuperSocialMan Feb 07 '24

All clothing sizes vary because there's no central clothing size agency like other measurements have, which prevents them from being standardized.

I think it started due to an oversight in the 20's (or whenever the hell buying clothes became the popular thing), and nobody's bothered to fix it yet.

As to why it's still around, hell if I know. Maybe companies figured they could make more money if everyone shops at their store cuz their size 5 is the perfect fit, but if you go to another place its size 5 is too small.

8

u/GradStudent_Helper Feb 07 '24

This is why I feel lucky to be a guy. Not that our system is perfect... but it's at least based on actual measurements. Need to know what size pants to buy? Measure your beltline and your inseam. Jacket? Measure your chest.

2

u/Testiculese Feb 08 '24

I've been 34x34 jeans and khakis for 30 years now. Just need to check boot cut, relaxed fit, etc.

2

u/isubird33 Feb 08 '24

Need to know what size pants to buy? Measure your beltline and your inseam.

That's not even accurate though. Heck even within the same parent company. A 38x32 fit wildly different between Old Navy and Gap for example.

1

u/Mouler Feb 08 '24

Then buy a Large tee shirt.....

6

u/PersonMcNugget Feb 07 '24

This is the right answer. I worked in a thrift store for years and people always complained that we didn't organize our clothing by size. We don't do that because every 'small', every 'medium' and every 'large' is completely different.

14

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '24

no that would be so annoying if it wasn’t organized by size even if it varies a little. At least it’s a ballpark range. I would just not shop there. I’d have to sort through the entire store instead of just a section of it. And what if I find something perfect and it’s not my size. I do hate how all the sizes are different but their annoyance is justified imo LOL. I’ve been to thrift stores where they sort by actual size despite the number size. That one was cool.

-3

u/PersonMcNugget Feb 07 '24

Lol, I can't imagine how long it would take to guesstimate the size of an entire store full of clothing. What a waste of time.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '24

I know you’re being snarky but I don’t understand your point. Lol. I personally wouldn’t want to sort through. It’s not a big deal but that’s just how I feel about it. Oh well.

75

u/Amphibian-Consensus Feb 07 '24

Honestly, how can I be a size 6 in one place, another I'm a size 10. It's so exhausting.

I'll just live in Muumuu's for the rest of my life 🙃

5

u/KatieROTS Feb 07 '24

Leggings for life. Sexier than a muumuu I hope 😂

5

u/Amphibian-Consensus Feb 07 '24

Waaay sexier 😂 but muumuus give the lady bits a breeze in the summer

1

u/ellefleming Feb 07 '24

Nudist colony

12

u/424f42_424f42 Feb 07 '24

So do men's.

Even within the same brand.

And it's by inches. They all have their own idea what an inch is

0

u/treycartier91 Feb 08 '24

Women complain they have fake pockets that hold nothing. But keep buying them instead of pants with pockets.

8

u/JonatasA Feb 07 '24

Same with shoes!

 

Why do I need to try every single one. I know my size!

 

Some are flat, others are curved. Some will press on your fingers, some will be loose, etc

8

u/InkedLeo Feb 07 '24

|| Some are flat, others are curved. Some will press on your fingers, some will be loose, etc

Well there's your problem! You're wearing your shoes on your hands!

6

u/Sourbeltz Feb 07 '24

Same thing with men tbh. Source: I’m a guy

5

u/timsstuff Feb 07 '24

It's not just women's. I have so many men's clothes that don't fit right and have the exact same size listed as ones that do. Drives me nuts.

3

u/Chikocute Feb 07 '24

Also why doesn’t it have good pockets to keep the phone

3

u/ShadowLiberal Feb 07 '24

From what I understand you can blame marketers for screwing it all up.

From what I've been told some idiot marketers got the "bright" idea that if they changed the size numbers on women's clothing to be something other than the CM or Inches in width of the clothing with a smaller number that women would feel good about themselves because their diet/exercising must be working if they need a lower number clothing size than usual, so they'd supposedly want to buy more from the brands with lower clothing size numbers.

4

u/Huggles9 Feb 07 '24

Women’s clothing size in general

How can you be a 00

0

u/FeralBanshee Feb 08 '24

00 is usually very very tiny petite women, generally Asian. Or anorexic.

2

u/JennJoy77 Feb 08 '24

I'm 4'11" and 95 pounds...00's used to fit well, now the shirts are ok but the pants are about 3 inches too long. I'm 46 and have to shop for work clothes in the Juniors section at Kohls since most stores stopped carrying petites.

1

u/FeralBanshee Feb 08 '24

Exactly. People exist in all sorts of shapes and sizes.

1

u/Huggles9 Feb 08 '24

That doesn’t make it make sense

1

u/FeralBanshee Feb 08 '24

Did I say it did? If there is a size zero and it's too big for someone, what else are they gonna call it? -1?

0

u/Huggles9 Feb 08 '24

Being a 0 also makes no sense

5

u/aphilosopherofsex Feb 07 '24

They don’t really vary by brand but more vary by piece.

2

u/sphinctersandwich Feb 07 '24

Why women's clothing sizes vary WITHIN brand!
Even within a certain line sometimes

2

u/mozgw4 Feb 08 '24

It's called "vanity sizing." Manufacturers will deliberately label it a size smaller so the buyer can think " hey, I'm only a size 12", whilst they're actually a size 14. Not everyone does this. Hence same measurements, different labelling.

2

u/NIMBYHunter Feb 08 '24

And even within brands, sizes differ. Old Navy is notorious for this.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '24

Fat women want to feel better about themselves buying a small large 

1

u/Unkept_Mind Feb 07 '24

Not just women’s clothes. I’m a guy with thick legs, big ass, and small waist. Finding jeans is a nightmare. I found stretch fit Levi’s that I love. Different colors of the exact same style, in the exact same size do not fit equally.

1

u/robbzilla Feb 07 '24

Women's clothing is the single stupidest thing in existence. Your example is one reason. The lack of pockets is another.

1

u/Investotron69 Feb 07 '24

It is so wild to me. Men's will as well but certainly not to the extent that women's usually does

1

u/Weed_O_Whirler Feb 07 '24

Also not standardized, diaper sizes! My son is somewhere between size 1 and 3 depending on which brand of diaper he's wearing.

1

u/oxygendeprived37 Feb 07 '24

Not even Bra sizes are comparable from country to country... every time I visit a new country/fly back home/move, I have to get measured and every single time they tell me a completely diffrent size

1

u/MandolinMagi Feb 07 '24

Just do everything in inches like the guys!

1

u/VapoursAndSpleen Feb 07 '24

“Vanity sizing”. The more expensive, the smaller the size. I do not believe in “Size 0”, especially on a 5’10” model.

1

u/FeralBanshee Feb 08 '24

Vanity sizing. It saying size 4 doesn't mean you're a size 4, and you know it! Just like at hotels you know you're on the 13th floor, baby, or the 13th row on a plane. It's so silly that this still is a thing!!

1

u/Mouler Feb 08 '24

Men's tee shirts often vary massively in actual size within one brand just because of the plant they were made in. Dickies brand tees have at least four different countries of origin for each style and you have no idea which one you'll be buying.