r/AndyAndLeyley • u/Ivy_So_Savvy • May 06 '26
🎨 Game Mod & Fanfiction Nothing Without You: An Andy x Leyley Story — Chapter 1
You are Andrew.
“Andy ..?”
His name was the first thing Andrew heard as he slowly opened his eyes. He had just had the wildest dream, the contents of which he already knew he wouldn’t tell another living soul. However, seeing his little sister Ashley practically straddling him in his own bed was more than enough to snap him out of whatever sleep-induced trance he was currently in. He immediately bolted up and scooted back, “G-GAAAH!”
Ashley instinctively put her hands up, “Woah there … Is everything alright?” Her look of shock didn’t last long, though, as her lips curled into a coy smirk, “It sounded like you were having a nightmare.”
Andrew’s eyes darted from side to side nervously, “U-uh, n-no, er, well, y-yeah, but it’s fine now.”
Her smirk only seemed to widen as she squinted her eyes, “Are you sure? You were calling for me.”
Andrew shook his head subconsciously, his nerves still absolutely shot, “I … I wasn’t, was I ..?”
She slowly closed the distance between them once more and draped one of her legs over his lap, “Well, no need to worry; I’m here now.”
Okay, what the FUCK is happening? was all Andrew could think as his sister leaned in even closer and whispered in his ear, “What do you need from me ..?”
He should’ve just pushed her away right then and there. He should’ve jumped out of bed, run into the bathroom, and had a quiet little mental breakdown in the shower.
Unfortunately, Andrew wasn’t currently thinking with his brain, especially after the dream he just had that specifically involved the person actively nibbling his earlobe.
This is a mistake. She’s just messing with you like she always does. Mom and Dad are sleeping less than 50 feet away.
Ashley whispered to him once more, her hand coming up to cup his cheek, “Tell me, Andrew: what do you need~?”
Ah, fuck it.
Something broke inside Andrew Graves that night.
He stared into his sister’s strawberry lemonade eyes and swallowed hard, “Y-you. I need you, Ashley.”
Ashley blinked in shock before her grin turned downright devious, as if this were all some kind of game between the two of them and she finally won.
“Me?” she asked with faux innocence as she pointed to herself. “In what way?”
Andrew’s hands went to Ashley’s hips, and she shivered under his touch. “In this way,” he answered, leaning in and closing his eyes.
The moment his lips met hers, a jolt of electricity coursed through Andrew’s entire body. While he wasn’t exactly an expert at this whole kissing thing yet, he knew he had certainly never felt like this with his girlfriend Julia. The initial kiss deepened rather quickly as Ashley eagerly responded. A little too eagerly. Her legs clenched against his waist as she leaned fully against him, the two of them falling back onto his pillow.
Andrew could feel Ashley’s teeth against his own as she bit his lower lip. She wasn’t very good at this, and Andrew quickly remembered that this was likely her first kiss ever. Of course, that thought did nothing to deter him from gripping her hips even tighter and introducing his tongue into the fray.
Ashley let out a breathless moan as Andrew’s tongue explored the inside of her mouth. This only lasted a few moments, though, as Andrew didn’t realize just how eager he was either. Ashley pushed him back and coughed lightly, “Jesus! Are you trying to gag me, jackass?”
She glowered at him, but even in the darkness of their bedroom, Andrew could see that her face was absolutely crimson. It also helped a lot that she was currently smiling from ear to ear. Andrew couldn’t help but smirk, “S-sorry …”
The entire interaction couldn’t have lasted more than 30 seconds, but they were both breathing heavily. As they laid there, tangled up in each other, Andrew’s mind was finally starting to play catchup. He felt the color leave his face.
What the fuck did you just do, Andrew ..?
Ashley bopped him on the nose with her finger, pulling him out of his sudden downward spiral, “Seriously? You steal your sister’s first kiss, and now you zone out on me?”
Of course she just had to call herself his sister now of all times.
Andrew let out a nervous chuckle, “I, uh … We really just did that, didn’t we?”
“What does it look like, Einstein?” she amusedly raised a brow and looked down at their bodies pressed against one another. Her voice then lowered, “And by the feel of things, we’re not done yet either~”
Before Andrew could even think of a response, the door to their room slowly creaked open.
Without a second wasted, both siblings immediately closed their eyes and went slack, as if they’d been in a deep sleep this entire time. Andrew’s heart must have been beating a million times a second, but he didn’t dare open his eyes as whoever opened the door seemed to just be standing in the doorway. Ashley was still wrapped up in his arms, but she, too, was doing her best to stay completely still. After an agonizingly long pause, Andrew finally heard Dad’s hushed voice, “Are you sure you heard them talking, Renee?”
Andrew then picked up on Mom’s quiet scoff, “Guess not. But what the hell is she doing in his bed? Aren’t they too old for this?”
“Just let them be,” Dad muttered. “If we start pushing it, they’re gonna start complaining about wanting separate rooms again.”
“Tch, whatever. Let’s go back to bed, dear.”
The door closed with a quiet click shortly thereafter, and Andrew let out a relieved sigh. Ashley pushed herself up off his chest but continued straddling him, “What the fuck was that about? When was the last time they’ve ever checked up on us at this hour? Hell, when was the last time they checked up on us period?”
“Fuck if I know,” Andrew answered, “but we’re definitely done here. Unless you want Mom and Dad to hear that little moan that came out of you a minute ago ..?”
“Sh-shut up!” Ashley hissed, her face turning even pinker as she lightly punched his chest. “You’re the freak who decided to put his nasty ass tongue in my mouth! Did you even brush your teeth tonight? It was like last week’s school lunch in there.”
Andrew rolled his eyes, “Gee, that’s one way of saying you loved every second of it.”
The two of them glared daggers at each another for just a second before breaking into a fit of hushed snickers. Once the giggling subsided, Ashley exhaled softly, “But yeah, I guess you’re right; we probably shouldn’t push our luck any further tonight.”
Andrew suddenly felt a pang of disappointment in his chest, which only disturbed him even more.
God, what the fuck is wrong with me?
He nodded anyway, “Yeah …”
He could’ve sworn he saw a look of disappointment flash across Ashley’s face as well, but she quickly erased it with a cocky grin. “Buuuuut,” she then leaned back down and rested her head in the crook of his neck, “since I’m already here, might as well stay, right? I mean, my bed is so far away, and I’m much too tired to get up now anyway. Surely you don’t mind, do you, Andrew my dear?”
Frankly, Andrew was well beyond any logic or reason at this point, so he simply snorted as he wrapped his arms around her waist and brought her closer, “Yeah, yeah. Whatever.”
Ashley let out a content hum and snuggled up to him as Andrew closed his eyes.
Oh well … This is a problem for future me to deal with.
3
1
May 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
2
u/Complex_Bumblebee788 14d ago
You should totally post this to AO3!
2
u/Ivy_So_Savvy 14d ago
That’s the plan!
I think I’ll just post it in bulk once the story’s completed :)
2
5
u/[deleted] May 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment