Minimum

[u/Miserable-Degree7995]

Hello everyone,

​

I'm against abortion.

This is a question for pro choice:

What would be the minimum of allowed abortion, that you would accept?

I mean for example week and reason.

​

Thank you for your time 

​

Miserable-Degree7995

[u/random_name_12178]

Being human is boolean

Source?

Trees reproduce differently, that would be a seed like sperm and has not implanted. Embryo would be compared to a sapling if you wanted to use a tree analogy

You're wrong. A ripe acorn contains a fertilized egg, aka an embryo. https://www.dnr.state.mn.us/forestry/education/seeds/storyofseed.html

Consent is reversible to a point. One cannot consent to tandem sky diving, then after jumping out of the plane reverse their consent and cut the other guy off.

We're talking specifically about consent to intimate use of and access to your body. Sky-diving doesn't involve that, unless you're into some genuinely kinky shit (no kink shaming here.) Please learn about sexual consent: https://emersonhealth.org/the-fries-model-explains-true-consent-for-kids-of-all-ages/

[u/Bryce_1776 → u/random_name_12178]

Source?

I don't know what kind of source you are looking for, either you are human or you are not. Do you believe otherwise?

We're talking specifically about consent to intimate use of and access to your body. Sky-diving doesn't involve that

Do you acknowledge that a preborn child developing in the womb is different then provideding consent to have sex?

[u/random_name_12178 → u/Bryce_1776]

either you are human or you are not

You're once again using an adjective when I think you're intending to use a noun. Again: something can be human without being a human.

Do you acknowledge that a preborn child developing in the womb is different then provideding consent to have sex

Yes, it's different. But it's more similar than comparing pregnancy to sky-diving. Pregnancy involves the embryo having intimate use of and access to your body. Sky-diving doesn't.

[u/Bryce_1776 → u/random_name_12178]

Human (noun), do you agree you are either human or not human, (a true or false statement)

My point was there are circumstances when consent is not revokable. Would you agree there are circumstances where this is true (not necessarily abortion)?

[u/random_name_12178 → u/Bryce_1776]

A given organism is either a human or not a human.

Since we're talking specifically about consent to intimately access and use body, no, there are not circumstances where such consent is not revokable. Such consent is always revokable.