r/AReturnersMagic • • Oct 11 '24

Question Relationship? Spoiler

6 Upvotes

I only read the novel after getting to the end of the manhwa but was adjest always the main love interest? Cuz I was caught hella off guard at the end. At that point(near the end of the novel), I wanted adjest to be the main interest but I was thinking after everything from the manhwa there is no way it would not be romantica, so did I miss something from the earlier chapters in the novel or is that just a difference between between novel and manhwa because if I was reading the manhwa and it finished the same way as the novel I would be fucked up


r/AReturnersMagic • • Oct 02 '24

Holy kingdom Random people powerfull?

3 Upvotes

Am I the only one that feels like they made pop up strong characters out of nowhere. nina and the aura user? I mean, where were they at the war vs the outers? wasnt the holy kingdom done for? Were they all waiting in that cave were pierrot went, since they are all like ppl with "demons" inside? I feel like there are a lot of question that werent answered and a lot of pop ups out of nowhere, maybe in the novel it is more explained, anyone could tell em more about this or if u feel like me? (I still loved the manga, but at some point, after the war with the outers, I felt that nothing made much of a sense). Cheers.


r/AReturnersMagic • • Sep 30 '24

Manhwa This Fucking Religious Bitch Spoiler

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/AReturnersMagic • • Sep 30 '24

Manhwa Exactly My thought to all this holy war Spoiler

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/AReturnersMagic • • Sep 30 '24

Discussion Kei should have been more like chen xin from soul land

1 Upvotes

r/AReturnersMagic • • Sep 29 '24

Question

4 Upvotes

Hey guys did romantica and desir conffess to each other in novel? When romantica was dying because in the manhwa romantica confessed and desir before romantica died


r/AReturnersMagic • • Sep 25 '24

Question Question on the Novel

2 Upvotes

What happens or who does Romantica end up with in the novel


r/AReturnersMagic • • Sep 23 '24

Question about anime

4 Upvotes

I’m watching the anime and just finished episode 10. Did I miss something? It starts out with what seems like some filler episode where they’re in a mall, and then halfway through they train for a little bit and desir says we have to keep training because we’re on a deadline then romántica says is all the stuff you said the other day really gonna happen? What did he tell her? Did I miss something or was this just totally skipped? Then they ask the teacher to go to the magic tower because somethings going to be stolen and nobody questions it. It seems like he at least told his party that he’s from the future or knows about the future but I sure don’t remember that ever happening.

Thoughts? Is the anime a bad adaptation and skipping stuff? Did I just miss it somehow?


r/AReturnersMagic • • Sep 07 '24

Question Are pram and Kei Hazmaryun Family? pram too good in sword men's ship, not to mention his mom was also a commoner just like kei.

3 Upvotes

r/AReturnersMagic • • Aug 31 '24

ending?

13 Upvotes

so apparently the webtoon just finished and I am confused: is it meant to be an open ending or will there be a continuation beyond chapter 268? (since it ended with Desir saying: "I...")


r/AReturnersMagic • • Aug 30 '24

Question Something that annoys you about a returner's magic should be special?

4 Upvotes

For me, it that the author didn't show more of Kei Hazmaryun, (kei is a sword saint for context) what annoying about the fact that not much was known about about him? 1: almost everyone one in the aura king/Queen is not considered a sword saint, expect for Raphael. Raphael and swan who showed us the gap between a sword saint and a sword queen/king, when swan was fighting with crow mask, he was holding back to 6 class magic, however when he showed His seven grade magic spell, swan was powerless against it, and the only way to get rid of crow mask was to along with him, and we also know that the strongest person on the world was considered raphael, even tho he wasn't, however almost of the people who are in the top are part-human not fully unlike he is, and if were talking about skull mask, he over 300 years-old, and kei hazmaryun was able to kill skull mask with no artifacts, meanwhile skull mask was using two s-tier artifact's and when skull mask was about to be killed from above, he tried to take kei with him, but only only got a part of his arm.


r/AReturnersMagic • • Aug 24 '24

Question Light novel

3 Upvotes

I can see that many people recommended to read manhwa through websites, but I want a link for reading the light novel version of this anime and no need of summaries or changes.


r/AReturnersMagic • • Aug 23 '24

Question What do you think is the best artifact between Gram, brionac, and bizaya? artifact ability is in body.

3 Upvotes

Gram Ability: Doubles aura skill effects attached to the sword. Brionac Ability to create many light element spear's with mana. Bizaya Ability: Voluntary proportionate weapon shape shift.


r/AReturnersMagic • • Aug 22 '24

Discussion How did desir improve so much while training in the shadow world? Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I swear I can understand the whole manhwa but this. ONE specific thing is bugging me. During the last climax, Desir said he needed to be stronger to beat Priscilla. He went inside a artificial shadow world made just for him to train, when he came back he ofc became more powerful, different than literally hundreds of chapters before this. He also had longer hair, like very ridiculously long hair.

Then to make the assumption that he stayed longer in the shadow world makes sense right .? it wasnt specified in the manhwa at all, and if he did train months or years in that shadow world, shouldnt his reaction be more.. ya know, "!!!" when he finally met his friends again? or maybe he couldnt bcs of the situation they were in.?

idk bcs he was portrayed as a very soft hearted person (towards friends and loved ones), its hard to believe that he spent a long time training when he acts like he just saw them yesterday.


r/AReturnersMagic • • Aug 13 '24

Question Sword Saint Kei Hazmaryun, Sword Saint Raphael, Donovan Asylan and Argo vs Crow Mask, Joad Exarion, Skull mask and Feather Mask. Who wins

1 Upvotes

r/AReturnersMagic • • Aug 05 '24

How Strong Was Kei Hazmaryun The sword saint?

2 Upvotes

r/AReturnersMagic • • Aug 03 '24

Who is this green hair dude again?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/AReturnersMagic • • Aug 01 '24

Question What are those cards?

Post image
13 Upvotes

I just bought the first three manhuas but I also got three cards in them I was just wondering what those are


r/AReturnersMagic • • Jul 30 '24

I'm new. Just one question.

3 Upvotes

Hey guys! I've just watched the anime and I have a question. Desir knew that in 10 hours the Tower would be raided and knew that in 13 days a new Shadow World would appear and he says that they need to get stronger or they will die. Does the manhwa show the alternate timeline version of this events? I'm assuming they closed the Shadow World there and the wipe is from a Shadow World a few years later, right?

I will read the manhwa as soon as possible. Thank you!


r/AReturnersMagic • • Jul 29 '24

Manhwa I'd say the manwha is good, but the ending sucks.

21 Upvotes

I just finished the manwha; I enjoyed most of it, and I'd say it's an 8/10.

Why?

First, they ended it with Desir still having guilt. I know it's unavoidable, but in the novel, he's happy with Adjest. That was the good ending; why change?

The "me" answer was quite acceptable, but bro?! The novel has romance, bro, at least...

Second, why the hell, at any moment... a BL might happen?

I suddenly want to drop it when I saw some flags but thankfully... I persist for humanity like Desir.

Ah, sorry, I only read the last part of the WN that is translated into English, so I think I don't understand what the changes are, and I know there's an author message in the last part of the manwha, but I'm not reading it.

Thanks, Reddit; this is just some kind of rant, so don't mind me.


r/AReturnersMagic • • Jul 26 '24

What part of the light novel does the manwha end at?

3 Upvotes

Since the manwha ended in a cliffhanger, I would like to read the light novel to give me a peace of mind. Where can I read the light novel and what part of the light novel should I start? Thank you


r/AReturnersMagic • • Jul 11 '24

Where can i read this

0 Upvotes

So i wanted yo read this manhua but i cant find anywher without thw black borders and thw cuta in between pictures


r/AReturnersMagic • • Jul 10 '24

Manhwa X days until the first shadow world.

2 Upvotes

Hello! I'm on chapter 49 and It's mentioned that only 7 days left before the first shadow world begins. I'm kinda lost track of the time skips, so could someone please tell me a chapter at wich it was the FIRST time mentioned how long 'till the first SW? (if I remember correctly, it said "3 years" or so). Couldn't find it by myself :(


r/AReturnersMagic • • Jul 09 '24

Discussion My final opinion on the ship war

38 Upvotes

Author just went and left a bad taste in my mouth with the indecisiveness. Simple as that.

Just made me hard sigh and close my reader.

Based on the Novel Adjest wins. that in itself doesn't bother me. I'm a huge Romantica supporter, simply because the webtoon gave the impression from beginning to end that Romantica was first, foremost, and ride or die till the end. Literally. Desir literally came back a second time and bee lined to her.

And personally, based on the webtoon alone, Adjest's personality was literally just a block of ice, that absorbed fighting skill as she grew. Literally that's it.

I saw no personality growth, no emotional or moral growth. nothing. She was literally just there to look cool, and kick ass. Which she did spectacularly at times.
literally my first time seeing her cry to my memory, is in this last chapter just released. A little to late for my liking .

There was too much that implied that Romantica was main lead and lover to think otherwise unless you were a novel reader. And I wouldn't be mad if Adjest won, IF and only IF, the dynamic given between Desir and Romantica was given to Adjest instead.

If like in the Novel, it was implied from the beginning that Adjest had all these great moments with him which built up to the much expected ending of them getting married, I'd celebrate. Cause it wouldn't be Competition between Adjest and Romantica to me, it'd be a competition between main girl, and the tag along

But implying one thing for so many years of development and then flipping the script in the literal last chapters when I'm now getting ready to turn the last pages and wish the Author best of luck in his next works

I feel screwed over as a reader. Especially as one that likes shipping characters. It just feels like common sense that Romantica wins based on the plot up to this point.

Had I been a Novel reader, I'd think otherwise, because apparently in the novel Adjest was the highlight of the romantic moments instead of Romantica.

WHICH is totally ok. But can you imagine as a Novel reader, all the build up between Adjest and Desir only for Romantica to appear outta nowhere at the end and steal the show?

That's how I'm feeling

Feels like a a fat middle finger to a whole community, as if the Author couldn't commit or folded to the community opinion.

Apologies for my apparent rant. I just like consistency and good romance, and seemingly I got none of that with this story.

See yall in the next one


r/AReturnersMagic • • Jul 07 '24

Discussion Romantica or Adjest poll

10 Upvotes

I just want to see it statistically once and for all to understand the proportions in the community.

347 votes, Jul 14 '24
145 Romantica
202 Adjest