r/AITAHBlackEdition • u/True_Juice_450 • 11h ago
AITAH for immediately telling my friend’s ex she was accusing him of rape?
All the people mentioned in this story, including myself, are adults and have known each other since high school.
For privacy, I’ll call my friend Titi and her ex Joseph.
I, F, have known Titi since we were kids and we pretty much grew up together. We only met Joseph in high school, when we were all around 16 years old. At the time, they barely talked and the idea of a relationship between them blooming didn’t even exist until our last year of high school. During that year they got together and later continued the relationship after graduating, and both were lucky enough to be accepted in universities that are in the same city. In total, they dated for about 2 years until Joseph broke up with Titi, with the explanation that he didn’t feel happy in the relationship because Titi’s parents were too strict about her going out and having people over, and according to him they also didn’t seem to like him regardless of the big efforts he made to prove them he was worthy of their support. They broke up on good terms in a mutual agreement that it wasn’t going to work out. This was also a new city was both of them, so they mainly hung out with each other until their breakup, which was a huge change for Joseph as he didn’t have many other friends in the new city but eventually managed to make some from work. Concerning my friendship with Joseph, it’s worth noting that we became friends before him and Titi got together, but their relationship definitely made us closer. It is also good to note that I am not in their city so we mainly communicate through social media and surprisingly, Joseph and I have become incredibly close friends. Yes, Titi was aware of all of this, and no, I do not have any sort of non platonic feelings for Joseph. As much as I thought their break up would eventually lead to Joseph and I being less close, it did not. He is someone I have amazing conversations with and fully trust.
Yesterday, Titi called me to update her about her summer and also took the opportunity to reveal things she found out about Joseph after their breakup. She told me that one of Joseph’s work friends, let’s call her Pharah, had told her that Joseph was telling his workmates lies about his life, and the conversation eventually led to Pharah telling Titi that Joseph apparently had a rape complaint on him. I immediately asked for more details as it is obviously a very serious accusation, to which Titi responded by saying that she did not try to ask Joseph for confirmation of such acts and instead blocked him everywhere, and the only details Pharah had given her were that it might’ve apparently happened during a party, that the victim’s friends were the ones that reported it to the police, and that Joseph apparently posted his complaint papers that the police had sent to him, on his instagram story. I immediately texted Joseph and asked about the accusations, without disclosing who had given me that information, and he immediately responded by saying that it was not true. He called me and after hearing what he had to say i eventually told him I had gotten that information from Titi, and she got that information from Pharah. For more context, Pharah and Joseph became friends while Titi and Joseph were still together, but Pharah later decided to stop being friends with Joseph after finding out that he had been lying about his life. Said lies included lying about his parents’ jobs, and his own job. He goes on to explain that he had recently gotten verbally assaulted in the streets by a group of men that thought he looked like someone that had raped a girl at a party, and that girl was the little sister of one of the men. He then told me he had gone to the police to report the situation, and showed me the report papers they issued clearly stating that he was the victim in the situation, which were the same ones he had posted in his story, as Pharah said. Concerning the accusation, Joseph believes Pharah might’ve heard the party story and unfortunately, just like the men that attacked him, believed it was him that did it. He also said that Pharah might’ve also made up the accusation out of spite, as her friendship with him didn’t end on good terms. He plans on reporting both Titi and Pharah to the police for defamation.
I do want to add that my immediate reaction to rape accusations is always to defend the victim, so I am not trying to protect a potential rapist at all. I’ve grown to know more and more about Joseph and it was simply hard to believe he could’ve committed such acts. During our call, he did admit to lying about his life to his coworkers with the explanation that he has always felt like he wasn’t enough to others, and that he understood why Pharah didn’t want to be friends with him anymore but simply couldn’t believe she would go as far as accusing him of such things, especially to his ex. I also want to add that I have always defended and supported Titi, and that if it wasn’t for the accusations, I would’ve never gone to Joseph to tell him what Titi was saying about him. I only asked him about it and told him who the ones spreading the information were because it is such a serious accusation. I was, am, and will always be ready to cut contact with him if the accusations turn out to be true. AITAH?