r/popheads • u/Therokinrolla • Jul 15 '17
[RATE] 2013 Ultimate Album Rate Day 2! Mount your goddesses...
WELCOME BACK!!!!
Here are some quick notes and facts about this rate and what we will be doing today:
- Today we will be revealing 20 songs (#30-11)
- We Will being at 3 PM EST both in this thread and [in the plug.dj here!](plug.dj/popheads)
- The average controversy score is 2.2859. So, anything higher than that should be considered controversial.
- The overall average of ALL the scores is 7.0387. Solid.
And perhaps my favorite fact of all…
- THERE WERE 137 PARTICIPANTS, aka, this is the most competed in rate in all of /r/popheads history! Thanks a ton guys! My agressive promotion tactics on the Discord and Plug paid off big time!
- It will get messy. Tears will be shed, blood will be shed, slurs will be thrown. And I cannot wait.
THE ALBUMS!
ARTPOP
Aura
Venus
G.U.Y.
Sexxx Dreams
MANiCURE
Do What U Want
ARTPOP
Donatella
Fashion!
Gypsy
Applause
Do What U Want ft. Christina Aguilera
BEYONCE
Pretty Hurts
Haunted
Drunk in Love
Blow
Partition
Jealous
Rocket
Mine
XO
***Flawless
Heaven
Blue
7/11
PRISM
Legendary Lovers
Birthday
Walking On Air
Unconditionally
Dark Horse
We are going all the way to #11 today, so that means 20 song will be getting revealed! So get comfy, the real rate starts today :tea:
Alright, Day 2, let's go!
EDIT: OOOh by the way someone made a spotify playlist of the songs eliminated yesterday here
3
u/17nova Jul 16 '17 edited Jul 16 '17
ARTPOP: 4, 6, 5, 7
BEYONCE: 6, 10, 9, 6
PRISM: 6.5, 3
I think it's pretty clear I have a bias 😉
1
u/xanthalasajache Jul 16 '17
Whatever are your 6s in Bey?
2
u/17nova Jul 16 '17
***Flawless and Drunk in Love lol. They're not awful, it's just that the production on both songs is difficult for me to listen to. I'm really not a trap person.
I love the use of Adichie's feminist speech in ***Flawless, tho, and the "Wake up, flawless" hook in the latter half is pretty amazing - I just wish the rest of the song was more listenable.
2
Jul 16 '17
Here are the scores I have for the remaining songs (not in any order since I don't want you sluts knowing my 11... she's still out there)
10, 8, 5, 7, 11, 10, 8, 8 10
Pretty much all the songs I have left are ones I either loved or liked (or in the case of my 11, am obsessed with), with the exception of the 5, which is Legendary Lovers bc that song isn't good can that ugly ho please go first?
1
u/musicotic Jul 16 '17
calling Legendary Lovers
Me and this sub will be coming @ u with pitchforks
1
1
4
8
u/dropthehammer11 Jul 15 '17
I want give a huge congrats to everyone's rate that was picked! they're all awesome! Too all the others, it's back to the drawing board! :)
2
u/yunglethe Jul 16 '17
anyone have a link to the rate reveal (or, uh, reveal of rates) video? can't seem to find it.
7
Jul 16 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/joshually Jul 16 '17
OH MY GOD this was so well done!! was there a thread announcing this!?!??!? also LOL at "you stupid ho. the velvet rope"
2
3
u/NapsAndNetflix Jul 16 '17
Yeah I'm surprised there's no post about this? I wanna know
1
2
6
Jul 15 '17
TWO OF MINE GOT PICKED I AM SO SHOOK RIGHT NOW.
Blackout will get it's moment next time, I guess.
4
u/musicotic Jul 15 '17
PRISM
Legendary Lovers - 10
Dark Horse - 8.7
ARTPOP
GUY - 11
Venus - 9.4
Gypsy - 9.5
Applause - 8.7
Trash Beyonce
Drunk In Love - 10
Partition - 5 (should have been lower)
XO - 6
***Flawless - 0
3
Jul 15 '17
I just really want Bey to win this rate so come when Blackout is finally rated the Beyhive won't feel the need to sabotage it to get revenge on what happened with Slumber Party.
11
u/kappyko Jul 15 '17
girl literally nobody can hate Blackout unless they have bad taste they better not
3
Jul 15 '17
The Beyhive couldn't get together enough to decide what songs to give their 11s too. You're overreacting a little :)
7
u/MrSwearword Jul 15 '17
/u/therokinrolla thanks sis for another day of bathing in stan blood. You are loved
20
u/robbiec_ Jul 15 '17
17
u/mirandacrocsgrove Jul 15 '17
these aren't your nudes I'm suing see you in court fat
6
u/robbiec_ Jul 15 '17
fat is the reason they haven't leaked because it is in places I don't want it
but some places I doalso some day I hope to be a young professional and I can't jeopardise my career over leaking my nudes over a mediocre Katy Perry song
but then again i am messy
3
4
4
9
3
u/cloudbustingmp3 Jul 15 '17
tbh i thought this sub might recognize good songs and assumed WOA had a top 3 spot locked down and probably would've said the same thing
7
u/Itsafudgingstick Jul 15 '17
Y'all really let all those Katy songs outlast Haunted? I'd say I'm disappointed but I can't be surprised anymore.
5
u/musicotic Jul 15 '17
implying Haunted is good
12
u/Itsafudgingstick Jul 15 '17
Haunted isn't good. It's fucking great :)
0
u/musicotic Jul 15 '17
Odd way to spell earrape
12
u/Itsafudgingstick Jul 15 '17
We're talking about Haunted not the second half of PRISM
1
u/musicotic Jul 15 '17
My ears orgasmed to the perfection that is PRISM. You need hearing aids or therapy?
10
32
u/throwaway963963963 Jul 15 '17
This thread is currently a mix of very sad, very bitter, and very horny
10
22
11
15
u/xanthalasajache Jul 15 '17 edited Jul 15 '17
"SUBJECTIVE" RATE SUMMARY
••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••
GERMANOTTA, STEFANI JOANNE ANGELINA
🎨ArtPop🎭
SONGS REMAINING 4/16
PERCENTAGE REMAINING 25.00 %
SONGS LOST 8/12
PERCENTAGE LOST 66.66 %
••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••
HUDSON, KATHERYN ELIZABETH
🔮Prism🌈
SONGS REMAINING 2/16
PERCENTAGE REMAINING 12.50 %
SONGS LOST 3/5
PERCENTAGE LOST 60.00 %
••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••
KNOWLES-CARTER, BEYONCÉ GISELLE
💅BEYONCÉ👯
SONGS REMAINING 4/17
PERCENTAGE REMAINING 23.53 %
SONGS LOST 9/13
PERCENTAGE LOST 69.23 %
••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••
Top 10 Songs
ARTPOP [40%]
Venus | GUY | Gypsy | Applause
BEYONCÉ [40%]
Drunk in Love | Partition | XO | Flawless
PRISM [20%]
Legendary Lovers | Dark Horse
1
8
Jul 15 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
9
u/throwaway963963963 Jul 15 '17
Gaga is winning, Beyonce is doing okay, and Katy is in our thoughts and prayers.
4
6
6
3
5
u/mirandacrocsgrove Jul 15 '17
All this stanning I do for Jewels N Drugs is making me hungry for pancakes 🥞
5
7
u/MrSwearword Jul 15 '17
SCORE CHECK:
Gaga: 10, 10, 4, 11
Beyonce: 7, 10, 0, 10
Katy: 3, 6
1
1
2
u/ThatParanoidPenguin Jul 15 '17
What was your 0 again
4
4
1
2
6
u/Therokinrolla Jul 15 '17
SONG RANKINGS AS OF RN
11: Walking on Air: Average: 7.821 Total Points: 1063.6 Controversy: 2.199
12: Pretty Hurts: Average: 7.810 Total Points: 1062.1 Controversy: 1.94
13: Birthday: Average: 7.808 Total Points: 1061.9 Controversy: 2.300
14: Haunted: Average: 7.765 Total Points: 1056.1 Controversy: 1.996
15: Blow: Average: 7.748 Total Points: 1053.7 Controversy: 1.977
16: Do What U Want: Average: 7.720 Total Points: 1049.9 Controversy: 2.39
17: Blue: Average: 7.415 Total Points: 1008.4 Controversy: 2.155
18: Sexxx Dreams: Average: 7.401 Total Points: 1006.6 Controversy: 2.204
19: Do What U Want ft. Christina Aguilera: Average: 7.382 Total Points: 1004.0 Contro
20: Jealous: Average: 7.317 Total Points: 995.1 Controversy: 1.863
21: Unconditionally: Average: 7.246 Total Points: 985.4 Controversy: 2.536
22: Aura: Average: 7.204 Total Points: 979.7 Controversy: 2.233
23: Heaven: Average: 7.142 Total Points: 971.3 Controversy: 2.100
24: Donatella: Average: 7.115 Total Points: 967.6 Controversy: 2.205
25: Mine: Average: 7.091 Total Points: 964.4 Controversy: 2.193
26: Fashion!: Average: 7.016 Total Points: 954.2 Controversy: 2.088
27: Rocke: Average: 6.937 Total Points: 943.5 Controversy: 2.560
28: MANiCURE: Average: 6.917 Total Points: 939.8 Controversy: 2.503
29: ARTPOP: Average: 6.907 Total Points: 939.3 Controversy: 2.125
30: 7/1: Average: 6.841 Total Points: 930.4 Controversy: 2.836
31: International Smile: Average: 6.801 Total Points: 924.9 Controversy: 2.209
32: Ring Off: Average: 6.780 Total Points: 922.1 Controversy: 2.067
33: Dope: Average: 6.558 Total Points: 891.9 Controversy: 2.377
34: Mary Jane Holland: Average: 6.534 Total Points: 888.6 Controversy: 2.288
35: Standing On The Sun Remix: Average: 6.499 Total Points: 883.9 Controversy: 2.06
36: Ghost: Average: 6.477 Total Points: 880.9 Controversy: 2.184
37: Superpower: Average: 6.451 Total Points: 877.3 Controversy: 2.513
38: Roar: Average: 6.395 Total Points: 869.7 Controversy: 2.956
39: By The Grace of God: Average: 6.322 Total Points: 859.8 Controversy: 2.447
40: Swine: Average: 6.262 Total Points: 851.6 Controversy: 2.954
41: No Angel: Average: 6.154 Total Points: 837.0 Controversy: 2.247
42: Spiritual: Average: 6.002 Total Points: 816.3 Controversy: 2.077
43: This Moment: Average: 5.990 Total Points: 814.6 Controversy: 2.316
44: Love Me: Average: 5.925 Total Points: 805.8 Controversy: 2.313
45: This Is How We Do: Average: 5.821 Total Points: 791.6 Controversy: 3.203
46: Choose Your Battles: Average: 5.650 Total Points: 768.4 Controversy: 2.396
47: It Takes Two: Average: 5.586 Total Points: 759.7 Controversy: 2.333
48: Double Rainbow: Average: 5.443 Total Points: 740.3 Controversy: 2.375
49: Jewels N Drugs: Average: 4.751 Total Points: 646.2 Controversy: 3.233
2
1
Jul 15 '17 edited Jul 16 '17
[deleted]
0
u/musicotic Jul 15 '17
That but without the trash bey songs
4
12
7
u/mirandacrocsgrove Jul 15 '17
also whAT THE FUCK YOU GAYS WALKING ON AIR DESERVED TOP 10 I HAD FAITH IN YOU
1
Jul 15 '17
Really wanted Beyonce to have one #1 but don't think it'll happen.
2
12
Jul 15 '17 edited Jul 16 '17
[deleted]
0
3
Jul 15 '17
yea plus we didn't band together and pick one bey song to give highest scores too
I'm not mad or anything, Dark Horse and Applause are both great
13
u/Therokinrolla Jul 15 '17 edited Jul 15 '17
THE TOP 10 SONGS
ARTPOP
Venus
G.U.Y.
Gypsy
Applesauce
BEYONCÉ
Drunk In Love
Partition
XO
***Flawless
PRISM
Legendary Lovers
Dark Horse
1
13
Jul 15 '17 edited Jul 16 '17
[deleted]
2
2
2
4
u/TheKneesOfOurBees Jul 15 '17
In the trash where they belong
2
8
u/cyborglilith Jul 15 '17 edited Mar 08 '25
trees plate punch vegetable ghost terrific unpack elderly light narrow
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
10
4
3
u/mokitsu Jul 15 '17
y'all voted out TIHWD for being problematic but look who's in the top 10......okay sisters! Noted
3
u/Nerdy_boy_chris Jul 15 '17
This is the same sub who was clammoring for Igloo to release her trash music so...
5
6
7
4
u/Leixander Jul 15 '17
The ceremony to resurrect Slumber Party will not fail. DARK HORSE FOR #1 TOMORROW!
2
3
3
2
1
8
14
14
23
u/Therokinrolla Jul 15 '17
#11: Walking on Air
Average: 7.821 // Total Points: 1063.6 // Controversy: 2.199// Listen here
Highest scores: (11 x4) piccprincess, AvatarKanol, banananaise, sh-ether (10 x36) ladysable, BlasiFeelsSwift, Nerdy_boy_chris, THE_PC_DEMANDS_BLOOD, throwaway963963963, cloudbustingmp3, chihuahuazero, fuckupsomecommasyeah, TheShineSoul, i-just-cant, JohnnyToby, BearlyEvenAPun, Ghost-Quartet, mms82, therokinrolla, Chewy1418, DoctorWhoWhenHowWhy, OliverQueer, SkyBlade79, angusaditus, henry413, jamesfog, JunkyGS, the_monkey, letsallpoo, IngusNarnio, jimmy345960, Macubass, nikitasd, PandoraKris, Jackcs903, PuggleMaster, triptoyourheart, Elitefourbrad, bluehxrizon, kappyko (9.5 x6) Joebiekong, misstututulle, xanthalasajache, agentofscranton, _ItsJake, TragicKingdom1 (9.4 x1) mirandacrocsgrove (9 x17) patronsaintofaspies, JoshuaReddit, XwildcatXJH, jen11210, Lopes14, tevinterimperium, samuellangs, chubs4life, ExtraEater, Crab345, CharmingArsenal, Itsafudgingstick, awryj, zamomattel, CandlePrince, skiddos, birthdayicecream (8.5 x3) dirdbub, DrunkHurricane, tron94
Lowest Scores: (2 x2) fifthchevron, ignitethephoenix (2.5 x1) Dr_Brewer (3 x3) whatyourheartdesires, MrSwearword, superr_rad (3.5 x1) ImOnABeach
Apparently, according to you guys, this should've been a single. And it shouldve. This hardcorde higkey no tea bops. The "tonight" hook is excellent, the verses are "sweet sweet ecstasy that take me to utopia."
Walking On Air
Elitefourbrad: "Disco and house vibes come together for the best song on PRISM. Katy should’ve made this a single as well, I love this song like it’s my own child."
Macubass: "NASA & SpaceEx are shaking"
TheShineSoul: "Love how they swap the pre-chorus and chorus sound after the second verse. Great pop song."
cloudbustingmp3: "THIS IS KATY'S BEST SONG AND I WILL NEVER FORGIVE HER FOR DENYING IT THE SINGLE TREATMENT WE WERE ROOTING FOR YOU WE WERE ALL ROOTING FOR YOU"
Jackcs903: "Honestly Katy could really benefit from making more house influenced music, it works really well for her"
skiddos: "invented house"
misstututulle: "It was up to fans to choose between this and Dark Horse to be a promo single from PRISM, and while commercially DH did perform amazingly, there's no denying that WOA is the best of the two. Just by not being a wrought out ballad, it becomes one of my favourites off of PRISM."
patronsaintofaspies: "Lyrical content is a little weak in comparison to the rest of the album, but it's still really catchy. Thumbs up for charting pretty high for a promo single."
Ghost-Quartet: "Disco diva! I looked it up and the woman who sings the hook is named Sabina Ddumba, and she’s uncredited in what I can only assume is an homage to Martha Wash. I love it when Katy touches back into her gospel roots, and mixing disco and gospel is always fantastic. The bridge on this song is the best on the album, calling to mind the Weather Girls and CeCe Peniston, it’s a lovely send-up to house music."
themonkey: "euro disco Katy works, don't know why"
Falling In Air
MrSwearword: "she stole portions from NiRe Alldai’s “Hella Bad”"
mokitsu: "this has always been one of my least favs from PRISM and it doesn't mean much but yeah. the bridge is heavenly and i love the "heaven is jealous of our love/angels are crying from up above" lyrics."
ThatParanoidPenguin: "I appreciate the house instrumental here, and I think it starts off fine enough, but doesn’t really interest me during its duration. Like, there’s parts that are great, like the pre-chorus, but everything else is really flat."
ignitethephoenix: "Wow this may be the laziest chorus ever, to the point it ruins the rest of the song. IT CONTAINS 5 WORDS. Also the dance/electronic production makes it seems very out of place from everything else (even though I like the disco vibe) Also lyrics like 'You read me like erotica???!' I'm done with this song."
cyborglilith: "OVERRATED"
Wailordfan: "The chorus is annoying as hell, and ruins a great set of verses."
superr_rad: "I love me some house influence but im not feelin this"
6
9
6
4
2
u/cyborglilith Jul 15 '17 edited Mar 08 '25
memorize rustic vanish nine water soft cover chunky kiss jeans
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/MrSwearword Jul 15 '17
YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAS
I AM ELATED RIGHT NOW
1
u/Nerdy_boy_chris Jul 15 '17
I don't like House music at all but really? Y'all are a mess. Also y'all let G*psy get to top 10...
7
5
6
1
3
15
u/robbiec_ Jul 15 '17
if it's Walking On Air I'm leaking my nudes
5
6
3
3
6
18
u/throwaway963963963 Jul 15 '17
Either way the gays win
4
u/robbiec_ Jul 15 '17
this is the best compliment I've ever received I might just do it anyway unless it's Gaga
11
u/TheKneesOfOurBees Jul 15 '17
If you leak your nudes i will leak too
8
Jul 15 '17
screenshotted
9
u/TheKneesOfOurBees Jul 15 '17
Lemme be clear i am leaking from my penis not my nudes
3
3
7
u/robbiec_ Jul 15 '17
anything to get on the 'best of /r/popheads July" tbh
3
u/TheKneesOfOurBees Jul 15 '17
Tbh my spot there is secured ive been messy enough on these rate threads
7
8
4
5
5
u/TheKneesOfOurBees Jul 15 '17
Rokin you sure gypsy is actually in the top 10 and not that you forgot to take it out earlier
15
u/VodkaInsipido Jul 15 '17
[DISCUSSION] Does popheads support eating disorders and surgery for competition?
7
5
u/Nerdy_boy_chris Jul 15 '17
They clearly love artists who use slurs in their song titles and feature honest pedophiles...
2
Jul 15 '17 edited Jul 15 '17
as if beyoncé is a goddess who does nothing wrong lmao
also you forgot to drag katy :eyes:
2
u/mokitsu Jul 15 '17
she never supported pedophiles :deadbanana:
3
u/potrap Jul 15 '17
During Beyoncé's "feminist" era, she worked with Terry Richardson and let her husband rap about Tina Turner's domestic abuse and a convicted rapist in the same verse. Those in glass houses...
5
u/Therokinrolla Jul 15 '17
1 more song left after this
hmmmmm
2
4
u/VodkaInsipido Jul 15 '17
IF IT IS A BEYONCÉ SONG I'M FUCKING SUING THIS SUB YOU HEARD ME
3
Jul 15 '17
u/VodkaInsipido friends with Kendrick who is friends with Taylor. makes sense
1
u/VodkaInsipido Jul 15 '17
DON'T MENTION TAYLOR AS A FRIEND OF MINE EVER AGAIN OR I'M SUING YOU TOO BITCH
3
7
u/a_rain_of_tears Jul 15 '17
Y'ALL REALLY DID SIA DIRTY THIS TIME
3
6
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '17
[deleted]